How bad did everyone smell before toilets were invented?

by [deleted]

Okay, this question risks sounding immature, but bare with me. I feel like we can address this topic in a serious and historical manner. This is a matter of important historical debate and we need to get to the bottom of this (no pun intended)

Before modern sewage systems were created, how bad was the smell in large urban areas? Lets specifically say in London, in the late Georgian era after massive urbanization began, but before any kind of complex system to deal with the refuse. Was everyone basically just taking a dump in a bucket then throwing it in the street? Wouldn't it just pile up in the streets? Were there people who's specific job was to take the poo away? Were certain neighbourhoods more well-known for the prevalence of feces than others? And what about the average people - "the great unwashwed" - if we met them today would we just think they smelled awful?

Searocksandtrees

hi! this sounds like two questions; here are a whole bunch of previous posts to get the ball rolling...

Sewage disposal prior to underground sewer systems

Question of defecation and fecal waste in the Stone Age and prehistory

The history of toiletry

How did ancient fortified cities handle sewage and guard against plague and fire?

why did medieval people put up with so much filth in their city streets? IF they didn't have the resources for modern plumbing, couldn't they at least hire armies of people to cart away waste?

How did urban people use the bathroom in the 18 & 19th centuries?

How effective were early street sweepers in clearing away the grime of the city streets?

If I were to wake up in 1880 New York City, how bad would it smell compared to the modern version?

Personal body odour

Did everybody "smell bad" in the in the medieval period?

Did history smell bad?

Is it safe to say that every single great person in history prior to, say, 1930, would, to our noses, smell just horrible?

In your field of study, what were the bathing practices of the middle class/common people? Also, how did they deal with the smell of body odor?

Did history smell bad?

Would pre-20th century people smell bad to us?

What sort of common things were used to cover up body odor until deodorant was common place?

Body odors before mass produced hygiene productds

Before the creation of luxuries like perfume (and before they were widely available to purchase); how did people feel about their personal smell?