Question about Medieval sieges

by edcokn

I read Medieval Sieges and Siegecraft by Geoffrey Hindley a little while ago. First of all is it a good source? Secondly he has an account of a siege in there, I think Calais, where the French defenders expelled the non-essential citizens mid siege to conserve food, the English didn't take them in and they starved at the foot of the wall. He also says this was not uncommon. So I guess my question is, is that all true?

lordflay

I haven't read that particular book I'm afraid, but if I remember correctly, it was the siege of Caen where the undesirables were expelled and forced to live between between the besiegers and the besieged. There are chronicles and sources describing that particular event happening. I'm not sure if its 'common', but it certainly could and did happen. It's interesting because Henry is not condemned for his actions of not permitting the civilians to cross his siege lines, he had absolutely no obligation to them. From the English viewpoint it was Caen's duty to protect its inhabitants, or surrender the city to the English if they couldn't. Indeed, leaving them there, suffering in view of the defenders, was probably a calculated move to some extent.