Why didn't complex, Pre-Columbian empires develop in North America like they did in Central and South America?

by [deleted]
[deleted]

There are a few answers in the FAQ on the topic which you may find interesting, although they're not really comprehensive explanations. The problem is that there are very few hard-and-fast "rules" that explain why cultures develop the way they do. Which means that it's almost impossible to explain a negative. It's much easier to explain "why did culture x develop the way it did" than "why didn't culture x develop like culture y."

I also want to point out two things: First, there were several complex societies in North America. Chaco Canyon and Cahokia were both cities with complex political systems that existed north of Mexico. Second, the idea that we don't include Mesoamerica as part of North America is based on modern political boundaries rather than on any geographic definition of North America. Prior to the arrival of Europeans, there were trade networks connecting Mesoamerica to the American Southwest. Granted there were vast cultural differences between the ancient Pueblo people and, for example, the Aztecs. But they weren't much larger than the differences between the Puebloans and the Mississippian cultures. The division separating them has more to do with modern borders between English vs. Spanish-speaking countries, which obviously doesn't apply to pre-Columbian cultures.

theothercoldwarkid

In the Cambridge History of Warfare, they talk a bit about how societies in the Americas waged war differently from Europe based on geography. In Europe, lots of different groups were crammed into a space between the Urals and the Iberian peninsula, and their wars were bloody and full of dead bodies. Hence, finding new ways to win was a premium skill, which led to a lot of information transfer and modification of warfare techniques.

Conversely, the North American continent was tremendous in size, and so with so much room between tribes and civilizations, war and sport kind of blended together into a weird kind of game of tag where enemies fought to capture each other to use as workers rather than to kill them. Or as one British officer put it, "The Indians might wage war for seven years and not kill seven men." The mark of a warrior in certain tribes would be to run up to an enemy, slap him with a stick, and run away, as a way of saying "I totally could have killed you, but didn't, because I'm better than that."

It's not the only reason people developed differently, but the sheer size of North America is enough to create different dynamics for cultures to develop in.

repeatwad

http://nationalhumanitiescenter.org/pds/amerbegin/exploration/text1/desoto.pdf A description of the peoples and towns De Soto encountered in the Southeast.