In Shakespeare's Macbeth, soldiers from an enemy army cut down the trees of Great Birnum Wood and used them as camouflage to get closer to Macbeth's castle at Dunsinane. Would this tactic ever have been used in a real 16th century siege, and if so, how effective would the move be?

by Kalros

Obviously the tactic couldn't conceal the soldiers once they came within a certain distance of the castle, but how much extra time could such a camouflage be expected to give to an advancing army, if the tactic was ever successfully pulled off?

itsallfolklore

Jacob Grimm suggested that this motif in Shakespeare's Scottish Play is based on a folk legend, itself inspired by the cutting of tree boughs for the May Day march of the young men into a village. See this source for example. I know you are not asking about the origin of the motif - but this evidence suggests that there may not have been an actual expression of this strategy on the battlefield. It is a dramatic, but not very effective motif

Pseudowoodoh

Not an answer, but a sort of clarification of the question; I've always been under the impression that Macbeth is set in the relatively distant past - 10th century maybe (not as far back as Lear, but not as recent as the Richard II)?

I mention this because it may be relevant to the answer, if there was in fact such a tactic in that time period but not in the 16th century.