Hello!
I was listening to Dan Carlin's Hardcore History, and I took special interest in a story he told about a french Soldier being killed by a firing squad (for listeners, the story is at about the 46 min mark).
The jist of the story is that BG Spears saw a squad of Soldiers leading a Soldier-prisoner away, and he could tell at once it was a firing squad and the Soldier would soon be dead.
He then told of a French General (General Ledame?) that spoke with the Soldier, asked him what his crime was, and then proceeded not only to justify the execution to the Soldier, but tell the Soldier that, even in his death, he is serving is country.
The story was very powerful. My jimmies were rustled. I am a Captain in the US Army, and I felt a deep connection to both the General and the Soldier-prisoner. I really want to use this to help frame a discussion with some of my fellow troops and officers.
However, after searching Google relentlessly for a source or a book about this, all I could come up with is one book by E.L. Spears. I plan to order the book, but it is going to be about two weeks before I will see it (I am stationed in Germany).
Is there any way you gents can help me track down a source for this story, and perhaps a book? If anyone here knows a lot about it, reference and background would be awesome.
Thanks!
According to this page on the University of Oregon website the entry that contains "1914se12:European western front | Brigadier General E.L. Spears described how a French General convinced a soldier, soon to die before a firing squad for deserting his post, that his death was in its way patriotic" can be found in Eyewitness to History on what looks like page 450. You can also get the book online at Amazon.
Edward Spears seems like an interesting guy, serving as a liaison officer between British and French forces in both world wars. I would view the story with a critical eye though and see who the original audience of the account was. It's possible some details were embellished or dramatised if it was intended for a newspaper or other public source.