The essay is for a European History course and the essay has to be about something around 1815-1945, and I am interested in classical music so I thought I would discuss Beethoven (it doesn't hurt that my teacher is a fan of Beethoven). I was originally considering comparing Beethoven with other composers, i.e. saying something like "Beethoven would be nothing without x" (I suppose Haydn/Mozart might work) or "x would be nothing without Beethoven". My only qualms are that the first option veers out of 1815-1945, and the second is almost too easy to argue given how influential Beethoven is/was.
So, I'm wondering if anyone can help me choose something to discuss/argue regarding Beethoven. Any help is appreciated. Thanks in advance!
When writing a thesis statement you want to make sure you avoid just making a declarative sentence like "Beethoven would be nothing without his friendship with Joseph Hadyn." Also, you don't want to just describe what you are talking about, i.e. "This is a paper that looks at Beethoven and Joseph Hadyn's friendship. You want to make a claim that what you are writing about offers a good example or illustration of something critical to the study of history. This would read something more like "Beethoven and Joseph Hadyn's close friendship demonstrates the importance of personal relationships to the development of classical music in the early nineteenth century." Does that make sense?
And I'm not suggesting you should write your paper on their friendship. I think studying Beethoven's income and his relationship with his patrons could provide you with some pretty interesting material. How does a musician actually provide for himself? Is he constrained by the desires of his royal patrons?
It says in our rules:
Our users aren't here to do your homework for you, but they might be willing to help. Remember: AskHistorians helps those who help themselves. Don't just give us your essay/assignment topic and ask us for ideas. Do some research of your own, then come to us with questions about what you've learned. This is explained further in this [META] thread.
You can also consider asking the helpful people at /r/HomeworkHelp.