Why did Alaska and Hawaii become states but the Philippines, Puerto Rico, and the other Pacific islands did not?

by waatpies
The_Alaskan

To add to the links that /u/Searocksandtrees provided, let me say this: Only Alaska and Hawaii -- among territories with adequate population -- had a widespread popular movement for statehood.

In Alaska, this movement started almost as soon as the Klondike Gold Rush brought large numbers of people to the territory. The electoral platform of the 1914 Democratic candidates, for example, called for a drive toward statehood as one of its key planks. In later years, the statehood drive reached a practical fervor, with all of the state's major newspapers backing it, a large majority of the state's population supporting it, and strong political movements supporting it.

Despite this intense pressure from inside Alaska, forces Outside were able to block the statehood movement for almost a decade out of fear that Alaska Congressmen (as they eventually did) would vote against segregation. That's getting away from your core question, however.

The key difference between Alaska and Hawaii and Puerto Rico/the Philippines was the proportion of the population demanding statehood. Not until the 2012 referendum did a majority of Puerto Ricans favor statehood, and even those results have been contested, given the structure of the ballot question. For most of the period in which /r/askhistorians operates, a majority of Puerto Ricans have favored independence or continued commonwealth status.

In the Philippines, a strong majority has favored independence for as long as the polling record indicates. The same is true for other Manifest Destiny annexationist targets, such as Cuba and Nicaragua.

Searocksandtrees
KyleBridge

An interesting theory (albeit one I don't particularly buy) is put forward by Eric Love in Race Over Empire. Essentially he argues that US policymakers, whether they wanted statehood for these places or not, were hamstrung by larger culture which rejected incorporating so many foreign, "nonwhite" people into the US population.