Without recordings, how do we know what ancient languages sounded like?

by solepsis

Especially The Great Vowel Shift. How do we know the sounds changed at all?

Searocksandtrees

hi! there have been lots of questions in the sub asking about pronunciation of ancient languages; I've taken this opportunity to round up a bunch with a view to creating a new section in the FAQ. The first bunch are generic "how do we know" posts, but you'll find additional info sprinkled throughout responses in the other threads too. Note that a couple of the threads on the Great Vowel Shift include links to videos that go into more detail. Enjoy!

How do we know?

Great Vowel Shift

Specific languages/names

edit: a link removed

NomenStulti

In regards to Latin, Evan Der Milner provides an excellent overview of how we know the ancient pronunciation. His basic points are:

  • Grammar books and pronunciation guides written by the ancients themselves - They themselves discussed how to pronounce certain words etc.
  • Translation of proper names and places into other languages preserved the original sounds
  • Comparing the development of the modern-day Romance Languages over time
  • Spelling mistakes in ancient grafitti and inscriptions - they spelled it how they pronounced it!
  • Poetry - we know that syllable stress follows a certain meter
  • Among others