Hey Reddit, do we have any account of what historical music sounded like?

by TheBrokenCog

I mean do we have any idea what music sounded like in, for example, the 12th century? Do we have any way of knowing what the music sounded like back then?

erus

Kind of.

We have surviving notations from that time. Western music notation was different from what we have now, but in principle deals with things that can give us an idea of what people were working with. We also have some texts that deal with theoretical matters. So we have tried to solved the puzzle based on those things (plus the experience of performers).

For the 12th century in Europe we can talk about Perotin the Great. Here, listen to this. You can see some notation in that video. Those signs tell us about the notes, but are not super specific about rhythm.

Do we really know how this all sounded exactly? Not exactly. Let's take some music by Guillaume de Machaut, from the 14th century, as an example. Listen to this interpretation by the Oxford Camerata. Nice, clean, precise smooth lines... Now listen to what Marcel Pérès proposes. A rather different way to sing, and added ornaments that remind us of eastern music.

We obviously don't have recordings from back then. At best we have problematic notations, theory books, and descriptions in texts.

Searocksandtrees