When did our superstition that opening an umbrella indoors brings bad luck come about,and why?

by Quixxeemoto
itsallfolklore

Great question, but there appears to be no good answer. This site is typical. Linking this to ancient Egypt is over the top; I really don't see how we could make a connection. It appears to be more of a coincidence.

The eighteenth-century references seem more plausible, although I have yet to find the primary source(s) upon which this is based. There is no question that a large umbrella opened in a small domicile is more than bad luck - it's simply a bad idea because the suddenly-sprung-open umbrella is likely to hit something or someone. I suspect that this is at the heart of it, but one could certainly look for the symbolic significance of a large dark shade descending over a living space as a reference to something ominous.

Sorry not to be able to provide anything definitive, but it appears that this is a good opportunity for additional work - if internet sources are any guide. I have nothing at my fingertips other than that.