Would the German economy have collapsed if Hitler had not started WW2?

by NihaoPanda
AThinker2

If Hitler never rose to power, then someone else might have taken over, or it would have collapsed entirely. Germany would either end up being broken up into smaller countries, or absorbed into the countries around it.

One of the few reasons why Hitler was even able to rise to power was because of the Treaty of Versailles. From the German perspective, it pretty much wreaked havoc on their economy, crippled their armies, and pretty much had them take the blame for EVERYTHING that happened in WW1. They weren't allowed to have a standing army, they had to give up all the land they stole, and had to leave Poland and Austria alone, even though many Austrians (at the time) believed they and Germany should be one country. There's so many rules they had to obey, and one of them was a 6.6 Billion dollar debt that was slapped on their lap. This, ultimately, crippled their economy, and to make matters even worse, they weren't allowed to trade overseas. Meaning, no shipments to and from China, India, and the like.

In layman's terms, yes. Germany would have fallen apart without someone like Hitler to bring them all back together.

Sources:

http://nstarzone.com/HITLER.html

http://historyguide.org/Europe/lecture11.html

Aerandir

Sorry, but your submission has been removed because we don't allow hypothetical questions. This sort of thing is better suited for /r/historicalwhatif.

bartieparty

This question has been asked a number of times, though I would be just as interested as you to read any responses you might also like to read the previous questions about this. As far as I can tell you it's still somewhat a matter of debate if this was the deciding factor. http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1dsif3/some_people_like_to_claim_that_nazi_germany_was/