I'm watching Singing in the Rain, made in 1952, and just noticed how amazingly white everyone's teeth are. Wouldn't most actors of this era smoke like crazy and therefor have yellow teeth? Did tooth whitening exist back then or are they wearing caps? Or were their teeth somehow edited in post production?
Some of this effect is the medium of Technicolor film messing with your relationship to color. Technicolor was not a very true-to-life color representation, everything is highly saturated, so reds look redder, blues look bluer, and of course whites look whiter. It's like a detergent ad! :) The Technicolor company had a color-corrector on site for filming to help work within the limitations of this filming system, like Dorothy's costume in the Wizard of Oz famously had a pale pink shirt, because the white would look too crazy bright on film. However I guess you've found a nice side-effect of the over-saturation - it made normal teeth look super great!