Day of Reflection | January 19, 2015–January 25, 2015

by AutoModerator

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Day of Reflection. Nobody can read everything that appears here each day, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

brigantus

Alas, after a run of two years, this will be the last Day of Reflection. Look for the newly rebranded but otherwise identical Sunday Digest next week.

Mictlantecuhtli
kaykhosrow

Yodatsracist had a great answer for What other prophets were there in the Middle East between 0 and 600 AD that attracted a sizable following?

I'd be interested to see how Germanic peoples were politically organized in this question: What was Germanic society like during 50 BC to 50 AD?

I'd really love to know more about piracy in the Mediterranean

What was life like for women in the Sassanid Empire? received one controversial answer.

1/23/15:

Doe22

Didn't get to read much on here this week, but there were a few things that I liked.

  • /u/an_ironic_username second entry on the history of whaling came in this week's Friday Free-for-All (here's the initial post if anyone's interested). I'm looking forward to future installments and I wonder if any other flaired users might try doing something similar.
  • /u/idkydi explained why dynamite was not the downfall of the Great Wall of China, no matter what Civilization V may have taught us. It was informative and I love the Civilization series, so I really enjoyed this one.
  • /u/yodatsracist gave a monster answer informing us all about the reliability of Ottoman census data and the movement of various populations after the break up of the Ottoman Empire. There are also ton of follow-on questions and answers in that thread that I'm still wading through.

As a side note, just from looking through that last thread with /u/yodatsracist's answer, I think that questions in this subreddit with a very high ratio of comments to votes are probably worth reading either because a) they're in a focused area that didn't draw broad attention but did go very deep, or b) they were posted at an inconvenient time but still managed to stimulate some good conversation.

brigantus

I also posted a pretty niche question this week and was disappointed (but not entirely surprised) it didn't get an answer:

Surely someone out there knows!