Did Irish slaves (not indentured servants), exist in the US? And if so, how badly was their treatment?

by Rotundum9

The thing that brought this up was this post that I found in a subreddit,

If anyone ever has to deal with the "You white people held my people as slaves." bullshit. You can easily piss them off, but only if you're of irish heritage. The Irish went through a very similar deal of being slaves. Except theirs was 10x worse than the African American slaves in generally the exact same time period. Often referred to as the "forgotten white slaves." Not only were Irish slaves cheaper, but there was absolutely no regulation on how they had to be treated. Black slaves in America were considered property, owners had to provide them with housing, food, and water. Regardless of the quality of those things, that's still better than what the Irish dealt with. Because they were considered tools, not property. You could break and kill your tools and go get a new one for very little money. So anytime a stupid black person pulls that shit on me, I explain how my ancestors were slaves around that time period too, and yet I'm not bitching about it.

Now I cant tell if there is a kernel of truth in it, or if its just a incredibly racist form of badhistory, that's trying undercut the struggles that African-Americans faced in their past by saying that white people went through it too. Any response would be great, thank you!

Hinmatoowyalahtqit

I wrote about this in length in this thread at /r/badhistory, based on this essay, which you really, really should read if you're curious about the Irish "slaves". "Irish slaves" is really toxic bad history because it is often used to justify blatant racism.

There's also a FAQ section about it.

jschooltiger

In addition to what /u/Hinmatoowyalahtqit had to say, there's also a meta post on this topic right now: http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/2w2fvs/meta_irish_slaves_question_why_is_this_such_a_hot/

The crucial thing to keep in mind (as you rightly distinguished in your post title) is that indentured servitude is a far different kettle of fish than chattel slavery.

Rotundum9

Thank you for your responses. I will be sure to check out the links you guys have suggested for me.