AMA - Deaf History in the United States and Around the World

by woofiegrrl

Hello everyone!

I was asked to conduct an AMA on the subject of Deaf History. I'm the only flaired user in /r/AskHistorians for Deaf History, so this is a great opportunity to ask anything you'd like to know!

My particular expertise is in U.S. Deaf history, but I am also familiar with European Deaf history and more around the world. I am a full-time public historian and museum professional. I have a BA in Deaf Studies with a minor in History, and I'm currently earning my MA in Applied History.

Please note that although I am Deaf myself, I am not speaking for the Deaf community here. If you have questions about culture - cochlear implants, sign language vs speech, etc - they might be better suited to /r/deaf. This is /r/AskHistorians so let's try to keep the questions history-focused. If it's a mix of both, I'll do my best to answer.

If you want to know about 19th century methods parents used to attempt to restore hearing, or how Gallaudet University came to have its first deaf president, or anything else - ask away!

Edit, 12am Eastern - I'm signing off for the night, but feel free to continue asking questions. I'll answer tomorrow!

lngwstksgk

In your interview for the AskHistorians tumblr you allude briefly to the founding of Gaulladet resulting from acts of abuse committed by a man I presume to have been a teacher of the deaf. Could you elaborate a bit about this incident?

I'm interested in the existence of Gaulladet as an institute of higher learning for Deaf adults--was this at all controversial at the time? How were Deaf people viewed, in terms of intelligence and general ability? I ask this because I have an uncle who was born in likely the late 30s or early 40s with a (presumably significant*) hearing impairment and was deemed stupid and thus not educated past first grade. Based on his experience, I had thought the view of Deaf people as unintelligent was widespread relatively recently.

*/ His hearing was never tested as a child and he has a "deaf accent", but was later almost fully deafened as an adult working in forestry (chainsaws with no ear protection).

Do you know about sign language linguistic relationships? I'm curious if LSQ (langue des signes de Québec) is also related to LSF (langue des signes française) as I understand ASL (American Sign Language) to be. Are there other linguistic "family trees" of sign languages?

Finally, I'm from London, Ontario, and am thus familiar with the "sign writing" research at Robard's. Have there been other attempts to write down sign language? Using characters unique to it, rather than borrowed from a spoken language?

itsallfolklore

Thanks for doing this. I am wondering about the history of jokes and stories that the hearing impaired tell and told. Do you know anything about what stories were once told and if/how they changed over time?

vertexoflife

I've been told by a deaf person that they did not want to speak to me because of their disgust at my hearing aids. I know there is also a lot of tension over cochlear implants and the idea of genetic modification. Deaf people dont see deafness as needing to be fixed. Where does this cultural exclusiveness come from?

vertexoflife

Hey there!

As someone who is hearing-impaired and uses hearing aids, I've always wondered what type of devices were used before modern hearing aids? Do we have evidence of early modern hearing aids?

vertexoflife

I've got another one! What is the history of ASL? Who came up with it and who formulated the signs? Is there is Academie of ASL that sets which signs mean what?

choirsofcacophony

hi! So glad you're doing this AMA! My question is: I know there's a lot of contention between the Deaf community and the larger disability community. Was there ever a point historically where Deaf people did consider themselves disabled? What about Deaf people who were also blind or had other conditions?

farquier

Where did the line between "hard of hearing" and deaf historically fall and how has it shifted over time?

vhcngh

Hoping you can answer this, but if not, no worries.

How long has the distinction between Deaf and deaf been widely understood/implemented/accepted among the community?

AshkenazeeYankee

So if modern ASL dates really only to the early 19th century, what were deaf folks doing to communicate for all the centuries before that?

caffarelli

This is very trivial, but are there any interesting name signs in ASL for historical figures? I know name signs are used for friends and family but I wonder if there are any historical figures that are talked about enough to merit a sign.

Othered
  1. Do you anything about any historical or contemporary indigenous sign languages in North America? Were there any distinct Deaf cultures in pre-colonial US or Canada? How far back do our sources go?

  2. I've been told that in Martha's Vineyard most hearing people would know sign language, and that deaf people were not really marginalized. How true is this? Was there a Deaf culture in Martha's Vineyard, separate from the mainstream hearing culture?

  3. Where can I learn more about MVSL? Did it develop from LSF, BSL, or emerge independently like Nicaraguan Sign Language?

spinosaurs70

what is deaf studies?

AshkenazeeYankee

So, I think you've mentioned this before, but:

To what degree can deaf history be treated as a subset of the emerging field of disability studies, and to what degree can deaf history be treated that a linguistic minority?

I've seen you make several references in your posts to the idea of the deaf community as a linguistic minority, but since most deaf individuals historically are raised by non-deaf parents and only learn sign at school, this makes them almost the polar opposite of most other conceptions of what defines the existence of a linguistic minority.

TimeZarg

Who would be on your list as significant/influential deaf people throughout history? People on the level of Pasteur, Curie, Einstein, etc? As a hard of hearing person, I rarely hear/read about people like that.

anthropology_nerd

Thanks for doing an AMA!

I'm interested in the development of American Sign Language, but I'm afraid I won't ask the question properly. Really, I'm interested in the origin and formalization of sign language, how the rules and signs were agreed upon, and what debate (if any) there was surrounding a more uniform sign language. I hope that makes sense.

Also, if you have time, can you talk a little about some of the aspects of deaf culture that those of the outside may not witness or know about? Jokes, slang, norms of behavior, etc.?

Thanks again!

BubbaMetzia

Can you tell us about the development of the Al-Sayyid Bedouin Sign Language, especially in how its origins differ from other sign language families.

icecreampuff

Okay, I'm a college student and I'm trying to write a paper. I am almost positive that cochlear implants are only possible because of the research done on deaf children sometime in maybe the 18th or 19th centuries. I need some sources so I can write about this, but I can barely find anything that supports my idea! Am I totally on the wrong track? Am I looking in the wrong place? oAo

WolfKingAdam

I'm a lad with partial hearing, and I gotta say thanks for doing this AMA. I don't have any questions, but hot damn diggidy I'm learning some interesting stuff.

Thanks! :D

spinosaurs70

have deaf people historically stonger arms and hands due to sign language and having to try commicute with their bodies?