In comparison with the Nazis, how cruel were the Japanese towards their enemies? Has their cruelty been exaggerated by American and Chinese propaganda? Did they have an ethnic cleansing program like the Nazis?

by rj_yul
Searocksandtrees

Hello everyone. This can be an emotionally-charged topic, so just a moderator reminder to all potential respondents to comply with this subreddit's rules for answering. A few excerpts:

Answers in this subreddit are expected to be of a level that historians would provide: comprehensive and informative. As such, all answers will be assessed against the standards of Historiography and Historical Method. You should cite or quote sources where possible. ...

An in-depth answer gives context to the events being discussed so that someone who is unfamiliar with the area can understand. An in-depth answer is usually more than a sentence or two. Use a balanced mix of context and explanation and sources and quotations in your answer. ...

Ask yourself these questions:

  • Do I have the expertise needed to answer this question?
  • Have I done research on this question?
  • Can I cite my sources?
  • Can I answer follow-up questions?

If you answer "Yes" to all of these questions, then proceed. If you answer "No" to one or more of these questions, seriously reconsider what you're posting.

Also a reminder that anecdotes, opinion/moralising, and conjecture are not permitted. Thanks all!

blackjacksandhookers

Imperial Japan acted with extreme cruelty during WW2. Allied prisoners of all nationalities were subjected to mistreatment and faced terrible mortality rates. The post-war Tokyo Tribunal estimated 27% of all Western prisoners died in Japanese captivity, which was far greater than the Western POW mortality rate in German captivity. This percentage was even higher for Chinese prisoners, with only 56 Chinese POWs being released by Japan at the end of the war. The infamous Bataan Death March of 1942 resulted in the deaths of thousands of Filipino and American prisoners, as a result of exhaustion, starvation, and direct abuse. This event exemplified Japanese treatment of POWs. Torture, death marches, forced labour, and mass executions were all common. When short on food some Japanese soldiers even cannibalized their prisoners.

The Japanese did not set up a "Final Solution"-type plan to fully exterminate any ethnic/religious group, but they did dehumanize other 'races' to justify their brutal subjugation. This racism helped motivate many of their war crimes. More than 20 million civilians died during Japan's occupations of Asia, most of them Chinese (though Indonesians, Filipinos, Koreans, Malays, Vietnamese, Cambodians, and Burmese also suffered). Western and Asian women of various ages were often exploited by the Japanese as prostitutes.

Sources:

Hidden Horrors: Japanese War Crimes in World War II by Y Tanaka

Hirohito and the Making of Modern Japan by Herbert P. Bix

The Looting of Asia by Chalmers Johnson

Comfort Women

Sexual Slavery in the Japanese Military During World War II by Yoshimi Yoshiaki

http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/war-crimes-wwii-japanese-practised-cannibalism-indian-soldiers-1460601