How did "Dick" go from being one of the most popular nicknames in America for a boy named Richard to a phallic nickname that has caused many of those men to shun being called "Dick"?

by jokemanmaker

Looking back in American history, it seems like the name Dick was at least as popular as John, if not moreso, at least for a time. Now nobody goes by Dick. Did calling a penis a "dick" not happen until very recently?

Searocksandtrees

greetings all!

We've had a big clear-out in this thread, which means it's time for a timely reminder of a couple of rules for answers. (bolding mine):

  1. expertise:

An in-depth answer gives context to the events being discussed so that someone who is unfamiliar with the area can understand. An in-depth answer is usually more than a sentence or two. Use a balanced mix of context and explanation and sources and quotations in your answer. Being able to use Google to find an article that seems related to the question does not magically make you an expert. If you can contribute nothing more than your skills at using Google to find an article, please don't post.

Ask yourself these questions:

  • Do I have the expertise needed to answer this question?
  • Have I done research on this question?
  • Can I cite my sources?
  • Can I answer follow-up questions?

If you answer "Yes" to all of these questions, then proceed. If you answer "No" to one or more of these questions, seriously reconsider what you're posting.

  1. source quality:

Sources are highly encouraged in all answers given in r/AskHistorians. A good answer will be supported by relevant and reliable sources. Primary sources are good. Secondary sources are also acceptable. However, tertiary sources such as Wikipedia are not as good. They are often useful for checking dates and facts, but not as good for interpretation and analysis. Furthermore, Wikipedia articles are open to random vandalism and can contain factual errors; therefore, please double-check anything you cite from Wikipedia. As outlined here, Wikipedia, or any other single tertiary resource, used by itself not a suitable basis for a comment in this subreddit.

thanks!

Searocksandtrees

there have been a few discussions on slang terms like "dick"; there's room for more info, but these are a good start

p.s. questions like these are actually etymology questions, so would be worth x-posting to (or just searching) /r/etymology

parco-molo

This is a question better suited for /r/linguistics or /r/etymology (although the latter is often full of lay men peddling bullshit urban legends) but I will add that "Dick" as a nickname for "Richard" is attested since the 1550s. It is rhyming slang (rhymes with Rick), as with "Bob" for Robert; many common English nicknames originated via this pattern.

"Dick" meaning penis is attested from 1891 from the Farmer's Slang dictionary, so it's not that new.