Were there ever any Islamic attempts to colonize the New World?

by _PM_ME_YOUR_SMILE

If there were, why did they fail? If not, why not? Did any Islamic leaders ever express interest?

mormengil

There were never any attempts.

The Ottoman empire was the most powerful Islamic nation at the time of the discovery of the new world, so they might be considered the most likely to think about it, but they never did.

The Ottomans had too much to keep them occupied closer to home, and they were too cut off from easy access to the New World by other (and hostile) powers to ever contemplate it.

For the first 50 or so years after the new world was discovered, the Ottomans were involved in unsuccessfully trying to eject the Portuguese militarily from the Indian Ocean (the Portuguese were threatening their revenues from the spice trade between the Orient and Europe, and the Indian Ocean threat was much closer to home than any possible opportunities in the New World).

Since Vasco da Gama arrived in the Indian Ocean in 1498, the Portuguese had been fighting Calicut and allying with the Kingdom of Cochin, to establish a spice trade back to Europe around the Cape of Good Hope and undercut the old trade routes through the Mediterranean which were controlled by Mamluk Egypt, the Ottoman Empire, and the Venetians.

In 1507, the Ottomans sent disassembled galleys to Egypt, which were reassembled on the red sea coast. These Turkish galleys, together with Mamluk vessels ventured into the Indian Ocean and surprised a small Portuguese fleet at Chaul in 1508. They captured one of the Portuguese ships and killed the Portuguese commander, Lourenco de Almeida. The rest of the Portuguese ships escaped. The Muslim fleet then sailed to the port of Diu.

The Portuguese viceroy in the Indian ocean was Francisco de Almeida, father of the commander who had been killed at Chaul. He was determined to defeat the Muslim fleet, both for strategic reasons, but also for revenge. He sent the Muslim fleet a message saying that he was going to revenge himself on them, and that if they did not fight he would take the City of Diu.

Such was Francisco’s thirst for revenge that he threw his replacement as Portuguese Viceroy in the Indian Ocean into jail so he could not interfere with or take command of Francisco’s naval war.

The combined fleet of the Mamluks, the Ottomans, the Sultan of Gujarat and the Zamorin of Calicut, amounted to 12 major ships (6 carracks and 6 galleys) and over 80 smaller local dhows. Franciso assembled 5 large ‘naus’, four smaller ‘naus’, four ‘caravelas redondas’, two ‘caravelas’, two galleys and one ‘bergantim’, and sailed these 18 ships to Diu.

The Muslim fleet decided not to come out to attack the Portuguese, but to defend the harbor of Diu, protected by the cannon of the harbor forts.

Francisco sailed straight in with all guns blazing. The entire Muslim fleet was destroyed or captured with great losses of sailors and soldiers. The Portuguese captured the port of Diu.

The strongly built, seaworthy, and powerfully cannon-armed Portuguese ships were the key technology which enabled the Europeans to dominate the Indian Ocean. No other power in the vast area could compete with this technology. No other power proved able to rapidly copy or duplicate this technology.

Franciso said, “as long as (we) may be powerful at sea (we) will hold India…If (we) do not possess this power, little will avail a fortress on the shore.”

The Ottomans made several subsequent attempts to reverse the defeat at Diu and re-challenge Portuguese control of the Indian Ocean. In 1538, they sent 54 ships to besiege Diu, but suffered a crushing defeat. In 1547, Suleiman the Magnificent sent another fleet to attack Diu, but this was also defeated, marking the end of Ottoman attempts to gain control of the Indian Ocean.

http://forum.worldofwarships.eu/index.php?/topic/2462-naval-battle-of-diu-indian-ocean-1509/ http://books.google.com/books?id=Kl3IR3RJTIEC&pg=PA213&lpg=PA213&dq=Portuguese+naval+battles+in+the+Indian+Ocean&source=bl&ots=iCN51Q98ha&sig=JOHw5oRgJGa1O1X99KavhmQwjlc&hl=en&sa=X&ei=LEJuU5nMFMeayASs74GQDw&ved=0CFoQ6AEwCQ#v=onepage&q=Portuguese%20naval%20battles%20in%20the%20Indian%20Ocean&f=false http://historyofislam.com/contents/onset-of-the-colonial-age/the-portuguese-devastations-in-the-indian-ocean/ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Diu_(1509)

So, until about 1550, the Ottomans were involved in a failing struggle to try to defeat the Portuguese in the Indian Ocean, which seemed much more important to them than any possible ventures to the New World (not that there is any evidence that they ever contemplated such).

During this period, the Ottomans were also heavily involved in expanding into Europe. In 1521 they captured Belgrade. In 1522 they conquered Rhodes. In 1526, at the battle of Mohacs, Suleiman the Magnificent defeated Hungary and Bohemia. In 1529 The Ottomans besieged (failed) Vienna. In 1533, they conquered Iraq (taking a break from European operations). In 1541 they conquered Budapest. In 1551 they took over Libya.

In 1571, however, the Ottomans lost the great naval battle of Lepanto in the Mediterranean against the forces of Venice, the Pope and the Hapsburgs. Although it would not be readily apparent for another 100 years, this is often seen as the beginning of the decline of the Ottoman Empire.

It might be possible to assert that the beginning of the decline was even earlier in 1509, when the Ottomans lost the battle of Diu and could not regain control of the Indian Ocean from the Portuguese. This gradually reduced Ottoman wealth from controlling the spice trade, and increased Western European wealth.

In any event, the Ottomans, if they had ever wanted to venture to the New World, would have needed to ship through either the Indian Ocean, which they lost control of by 1509, or through the Mediterranean, which they lost control of in 1571 (although prior to that they had never had enough control to be able to confidently send ships past the Italians, Spanish and Portuguese into the Atlantic and back).

So, the Ottoman’s had better use for their resources closer to home, and never had the power to access the New World securely from their home bases.

Mr_Quinn

Believe it or not, this question has actually been asked a couple times before - you can find the most recent thread here, and the first comment in that thread links to several more discussions on the subject. I hope this answers your question!