Were rowboats used to pull ships during combat like at the start of Master and Commander?

by Sinkust

Here's the scene. Was this an actual tactic?

skiddleybop

What you're seeing in that scene isn't a standard tactic, it's an improvised solution to a unique situation.

Generally speaking if you're going to fight a ship, you want as many of your crew as possible on the actual ship doing the actual fighting.

ExOttoyuhr

I think that oared boats were used as tugs in harbor; there's a passage in one of Conrad's novels, I think, that describes this.

There's also at least one case of a warship using boats for mobility at sea, although this was to avoid battle instead of during it. Very early in the War of 1812, the USS Constitution mistook a squadron of five British frigates for the rest of the "Original Six" American frigates; when the crew realized their mistake, no wind was blowing and the British were very close. The Constitution launched her boats, which towed her away; the British then launched theirs, which towed them after the Constitution. Eventually, the Constitution dumped 2,000 gallons of drinking water, and with that lightened load escaped after a 57-hour chase.

That said, /u/skiddleybop is correct: this appears to have been a spur-of-the-moment improvisation, and it definitely wasn't something that a ship would do during combat. Remember that during combat, most ships would have marksmen in the rigging, and most warships carried light swivel guns firing grapeshot; a boat's crew would have been extremely vulnerable to those sorts of weapons, while a ship offered more protection.

billyboy77walters

While at the USS Constitution museum in Boston, I read a display about how that tactic was used when they were being chased or chasing and there was no wind. I recall it was very tiring for the crew but the alternative was to be captured or sunk.