Why has Canada ended up with a much, much smaller population than the USA, despite its somewhat similar origins as a British colony, proximity, size and immigrant diversity?

by Turbotroll

There are a lot of reasons, clearly. I would really like to hear which AskHistorians thinks are the most important. (It's not THAT cold!..Right?)

gnorrn

As this map shows, there is little difference in population density between adjacent regions of Canada and the USA. The geography and climate of the USA includes a lot more land capable of supporting dense populations.

smokesinquantity

In short. It's cold. Most of the land area is inhospitable for a lot of the year, and they can't grow anything or support livestock so far north. Like siberia.

DigitalUser

I worked for a very large Canadian Corporation from Winnipeg once. It was explained to me that its colder in Canada in general. Like -50 to -40 deg below in the winter in Winnipeg and that is a Large City. So Cold that planes don't fly as it is to cold. Also the engines can freeze quickly if they shut off after they land at cold temps.