I've been doing some general reading about the European front, and I find it interesting how despite being the leaders in aviation technology, Germany did not have that much of an advantage over the Allies. Is it because of how they used their air force, or are there deeper reasons?
Without getting into an absolutely massive post with, in a way, speculations about what the Germans could've, would've, should've done in terms of operations, there are a few main points I would highlight regarding the German Luftwaffe in WW2.
Not only was there the political interference so typical of Nazi Germany, certainly not exclusive to the Luftwaffe, there is also the interesting interplay between aircraft production and pilot training.
In the early years of the war, Battle of Britain for example, the German aircraft industry was, in a way, quite inefficient. They were not particularly good at replacing losses. If you look at the fighter (arguably the most important part of an airforce) production for those early war months, it is actually quite low. Over England and the Channel in 1940, the Germans lost more aircraft than they could produce, thinning the numbers of the Luftwaffe. The beleaguered British, in contrast, did manage to keep production up to a certain level to better replace aircraft losses. Lack of fighters was a real problem for the early war Luftwaffe during the BoB.
Now, what ties in with this is that the Luftwaffe basically had their pilots on 'endless rotation'. We've all heard of the German aces with incredible kill counts. Hartmann, Rall, Barkhorn, the list is huge. One of the reason these men accumulated so many aerial victories is because they were never permanently 'pulled' from combat assignments. They flew until they died or couldn't fly anymore.
In contrast, the Allied nations pulled experienced, combat-hardened pilots after a while to go back home and train the new guys. This is incredibly important as we'll see in a minute. The fact that experienced pilots taught the rookies things that really only a combat veteran could know meant that the standard of training for raw allied pilot recruits was not too shabby at all.
Now, the Germans like to train, and pre-war they certainly had a cadre of very, very well-trained pilots, in part helped by the government's sponsoring and encouragement for civilian flying clubs. But of course, pre-war no one had any relevant combat experience. And here's the kicker, the Germans didn't send experienced pilots home much to train the new guard. So as the war progressed, green Allied pilots were coming out of training with a much better foundation to be a combat pilot than the green German pilots were, who were often NOT trained by experienced combat veterans, because the combat veterans were still in combat, sometimes for years, hell, sometimes for the entire war (Rall for example).
This eventually turned out to be a massive problem for Germany in the later war years. Aircraft and especially fighter production were the highest in 1944, achieving staggering numbers of production. But by now, whilst they had enough planes, now they didn't have enough pilots. Fuel shortages meant training was limited and the German policy of 'fight till you die' meant training in itself was already limited in terms of what you learned, because there are very few good teachers. As experienced pilots kept falling in combat, the replacements barely ever rose to their level, especially later in the war, due to extremely limited training.
At the end of the day, there are dozens of factors that impacted the Luftwaffe in WW2, but when we are talking about 'efficiency' on a very meta-scale, I think the low aircraft production in the early years coupled with their inability to produce decent pilot replacements in the later years constituted a very detrimental interplay for the Luftwaffe throughout the war.
hi.. just a quick mod note to both the OP and potential answerers: this subreddit does not permit "what if" questions, nor answers based on speculation/conjecture. However this post has been left up because there's enough left to tackle here: How did the Germans not use their air force & tech effectively? Are there deeper reasons?
OP, if you'd like to pursue "could there have been a different outcome", consider x-posting to /r/HistoryWhatIf
I would have to question, to a degree, the premise that Germany was a “leader” in aviation technology. The P-51’s ability to escort bombers deep in Germany was more decisive in winning the air war in Europe than the ability of Me 262s to outrun the bombers and their escorts. Contrast the size of the V-2’s 1-ton warhead to the 4,500 lbs of bombs that a B-17 could carry on a long-range mission. Even the He 111 used the in Battle of Britain could carry 4,400 lbs on a medium-range mission. While the Me 262, V-1, and V-2 were impressive and technologically advanced, development of those weapons diverted resources that could have gone to increasing the size of the “traditional” piston-engine fighter fleets.
The reason that Germany did not have an advantage over the Allies was that the allies, in essence, committed themselves to the destruction of the Luftwaffe as an effective fighting force. Post-Dunkirk, the allied strategy was centered on the invasion and liberation of occupied Europe. To this end, they realized that the success of any invasion would hinge on who controlled the skies above the landing beaches. Luftwaffe doctrine called for airplanes to be used in a tactical role, supporting ground and naval forces as a sort of airborne artillery. The allies had to neutralize that threat in order for any amphibious assault to succeed. Every fighter shot down during these dogfights was a fighter (and potentially a pilot) unable to participate in repelling the Normandy invasion.
The daylight raids of B-17s and B-24s did not cripple the German production machine. The largest raid aimed at those targets, the Schweinfurt-Regensburg mission, was at best a Phyrric victory for the allies. The effect on German industry was not worth the losses of unescorted bombers.
The main contribution of the bombers was to force the Luftwaffe to come up and defend the skies, at which point the Allied escort fighters would attempt to shoot down the Luftwaffe. In February 1944, the USAAF launched the “big week”, intended to bring about a decisive battle with Luftwaffe fighters. After this, the fighters were unleashed from the bombers, allowing them to race ahead and engage German fighters wherever they could be found.
Just having access to higher/greater technology isn’t enough to win a battle or a war. The allies had the advantages of a clear goal and the resources necessary to pursue it with vigor.
Source: To Command the Sky, Smithsonian Press