Which, generally speaking was a better formation in battle - a Macedonian phalanx or a Greek Phalanx?

by Rhysrus
LegalAction

Seems a little bit of reading might go a long way to help answer this question. Chaeronea might be the paradigm case. You might also want to compare how Xenophon, Lysander, and Agesilaus did against the Persians to Alexander.