Did Frederick the Great, Antoine-Augustin Parmentier and Ioannis Kapodistrias really all use reverse psychology to introduce the potato to their respective countries?

by Hazlzz

Right now the top post on /r/TodayILearned claims that the French agronomist Parmentier tricked his countrymen into adopting the crop by locking up a large quantity of it and instructing guards to accept all bribes. I have "always known" that outlawing the plant for other than his own personal use was how Frederick the Great introduced the potato to Prussia - and then the first comment on the TIL claims the same story for the Greek Kapodistrias.

Since Frederick was ahead of the other two, it is of course possible that they heard the story and decided to try it out for themselves, and that human nature took care of the rest. But it also sounds like too perfect a story - the genius statesman fooling his own obstinate people into changing for their own good - not to suspect the stories have been, if not fictionalized, then mixed together somewhat.

What do we really know about this?

Jan_van_Bergen

So this is one of those stories that goes around that has a kernel of truth, but is way more outlandish than the actual story.

Potatoes were introduced into Europe in the 16th century as part of the Colombian exchange. Initially, they were extremely expensive so they were considered a delicacy. Some aristocrats and royals (edit: here I'm mostly referring to England and Iberia) even believed they had aphrodisiac qualities, which only increased both the price and desire of the plant among the upper classes. The masses, however, did not share the aristocracy's initial views and instead greeted the potato with suspicion and derision.

It's eventual spread to the masses, like so much of European history, is dictated by warfare. Warfare in the early modern period was often accompanied by starvation of the local populace as grain stores were used up and harvests were destroyed by armies on the march. In many ways, the Thirty Years War was the climax of this cycle of warfare and deprivation in Europe in the early modern period, especially in German speaking Central Europe. It is from this point that the spread of the potato is particularly well documented. It was first widely adopted in Alsace in the second half of 17th century; in Flanders at the end of the 17th century, and in Prussia during the middle of the 18th century. During the early part of the War of the Austrian Succession, Frederick II's government distributed potato seed free of charge to all parts of his realms and greatly encouraged cultivation of the crop. When French, Austrian, and Russian armies invaded Prussia a short time later during the Seven Years War, it was in large part thanks to the potato that Frederick's peasants were able to weather the storm. The invading armies took note of this new crop and brought it back with them, and those countries began, more or less, encouraging their own farmers to plant the crop. In German speaking Central Europe, the potato was again proved to be so good at keeping the masses fed that the War of the Bavarian Succession (1778-9) was also known as the Kartoffelkrieg ("Potato War") because, although the armies (Prussia v. Austria) themselves basically stalemated, everyone went home well fed, thanks to the starchy root vegetable. As a result, primarily of Frederick's exploits, the potato went from either unknown or despised by the masses in much of Europe at the beginning of the 18th century to a major part of the European diet by the end of the century.

Its spread in France was a bit slower than elsewhere, however, but it is also related to war. Parmentier was taken prisoner by the Prussians during the Seven Years War and survived for three years in captivity on a steady diet of potatoes. When he was released in 1763, he was not much worse for wear either. So he returned to France determined to introduce the potato to France. He began with a number of scientific studies proving the nutritional value of the crop. When harvests failed in 1770, the Besancon Academy offered a prize for the best study of food substances that could help alleviate the calamities of famine, Parmentier entered his own potato study and won the prize. In 1775, after the so-called Flour War, Parmentier began trying to get government backing for use of the potato to help with the food shortages in Paris. It wasn't until 1785 that he got that royal seal of approval. So Parmentier began by wooing the high society. He hosted dinner parties (guests included Ben Franklin and Thomas Jefferson) and even managed to get the potato served at court. But given the popularity of the aristocracy in Ancien Regime France, this did little to persuade the Parisian masses. His royal seal of approval, however, permitted him to plant a whopping 40 acres (which yielded literally tons of potatoes). And he did do a bit of trickery to get the common folks interested. He posted guards and had the guards shoo away anyone coming near the fields, but then left the fields unguarded at night. Obviously, inquiring minds returned at night to see what was so valuable and many absconded with the potatoes. Over the next decade or so, eating the previously despised crop became routine, such that Parmentier was inducted into the Legion d'Honneur as one of its first members in 1802, primarily as a result of his work with the potato.

My source doesn't mention Kapodistrias, so I cannot offer any insight there. Sorry on that.

Source: Reader, John. Potato: A History of the Propitious Esculent. New Haven: Yale University Press, 2009.