When did the image of the "reluctant warrior" come about?

by seeyaspacecowboy

Hello everyone,

I was just watching this video where veterans discuss their first kill. It was really profound, but by the end it struck me that this idea that a warrior should be reluctant to do the thing they were trained to do has to be a modern or at least recent concept. Obviously there are plenty of legends about martial prowess (eg the Iliad) , but modern war myths are typically about surviving against the odds (eg Black Hawk Down) or the psychological horrors of war (eg Full Metal Jacket).

So my question is two fold: 1) Is this exclusively an American or "Western" phenomenon 2) When did this transition come about?

seeyaspacecowboy

I would imagine that books like All Quiet on the Western Front and the horror of WWI contributed, but then there's plenty of WWII propaganda with a warrior mentality (although I suppose a lot of that was about "defending the homeland" or "sticking it to Hitler/Tojo"). Anyway I'm kinda just thinking out loud right now, so forgive me if it's not that focused. Hopefully it can generate some good discussion.