When some say that the American Civil War had the most American Deaths of any war . . .

by PibRm

Are they counting the Confederates as Americans as well? If so, is that what gives that war such a high death toll for Americans?

thetinymanticore

The Confederates are considered Americans. The Confederate States of American was seen as illegal and therefore illegitimate by the United States government, meaning that the confederates were rebels, but still maintained their American identity. This is why the Civil War had the highest American death toll, it was Americans killing Americans.