A Marine’s first general order is, “Take charge of this post and all government property in view.” In 1921 Naval Secretary Denby directed the marines to shoot and never surrender against stage coach bandits attempting to steal the mail. How did the marines get in charge of mail and what changed?

by NumNumLobster

I tried to read the rules and don't think I'm violating anything but this question is based off of this comment: https://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/3yxknn/the_united_states_postal_service_doesnt_play_games/cyhnxj3

I googled the quote and its sourced all over ( https://fixbayonetsusmc.wordpress.com/2015/01/30/general-order-no-1/ ) .

I am curious about how the Navy wound up in charge here and why not another federal agency (such as the army) particularly on land based routes. I am also curious if they still have authority here and how/if that has changed.

Thanks

white_light-king

The Army couldn't be called in without an act of Congress because of the 1877 Posse Comitatus Act, which specifically forbids the army from being used to enforce federal law domestically without congressional approval. This law was passed in 1877 to address southern concerns about federal troops after the civil war and not updated until after WWII. The Marine Corps is not mentioned by the act, which refers specifically to the "Army of the United States." Of course, the Marines have generally followed the spirit of the act, but they were not technically bound by it.

Other Federal Law enforcement agencies were practically non-existant at the time. The Secret Service and FBI were small, the U.S. Marshalls service was already committed to other roles and the postal inspectors lacked the manpower.

That left the Marines. Since they had expeditionary forces in readiness, they could muster 2000 or so troops on short notice. They had two brief deployments in 1921 and again in 1926 until more permanent mail security arrangements could be organized.

LetsGo

To be clear, the reference to "post" in a Marine's first general order for sentries refers to the place where the Marine has been told to do sentry duty. It is not a reference to "post" as in the U.S. Postal Service. Accordingly, the first sentence in OP's question has no relevance to the second and third sentences.