Is the Adoration of Christ an early depiction of Down's syndrome?

by kyleg5

I just read this article about Down's syndrome that leads with an anecdote about The Adoration of the Christ Child being an early possible depiction of Down's Syndrome (and extrapolating that this indicated the perceived angelicness of these individuals).

This seemed like the kind of tenuous claim a columnist might make without much actual legitimacy. I did some googling and found one article on the subject, but I was curious if this claim is that of a single crack pot professor or if this is more widely endorsed in art history.

alice-in-canada-land

I think it's important to point out that you mean The Adoration of the Christ Child by a Follower of Jan Joest of Kalkar.

There are many paintings by many artists depicting this scene, and it could be confusing at first glance.

I have no idea if there is any historical evidence, other than the painting itself - which is open to interpretation - that this is indeed a depiction of Down's syndrome. Interested to see what an expert might have to say...