Rules Roundtable #4: /R/ASKHISTORIANS WANTS YOU TO HIT THE REPORT BUTTON. Click here to learn one amazing trick anyone can do to make the subreddit better!

by vertexoflife

Hello again! Welcome to another episode in our Rules Roundtables, which feature us, the moderators, and your hosts explaining in comprehensive and hopefully comprehensible posts on the rules that make our subreddit great!

Today’s roundtable is on everyone’s favorite topic: REPORTING.

Why bother reporting you ask? WELL I’M SO GLAD YOU ASKED, HYPOTHETICAL PERSON!

Reporting is the one way each and every one of you can contribute! Reporting is also really important to us because it helps us maintain and improve the quality of our subreddit and our community. Because even though there are a lot of us moderators, and we work really hard to catch everything that goes against our rules, we don’t always manage to see everything (despite accusations in modmail, we are not Big Brother. Or The [insertgrouphere] Cabal. Or the Illuminati (well...maybe).

So if you see anything that breaks our rules or a post that fails to provide a source after being asked for them, or anything of the sort, then you know what you should do: REPORT. Go ahead, try it on this post, it won’t hurt me!

“But wait!” you say, “HOW do I go about providing the moderators with the very valuable contribution of reporting a comment?”

Well, thank you for asking! Here’s a helpful little imgur guide.

  1. See the question.
  2. See the rule breaking comment. (NOTE: Don't try doing this unless you fancy yourself a ban)
  3. Click the report button.

Please choose the option closest as to why you think the comment or question is reportable—this helps us figure it out going in. Furthermore, if you feel like there is another reason, or you cant fit your report reason into the “other box” feel free to modmail us! We much prefer you to fill out the 'other' box.

Just to let you know: no, we sadly(?) cant see your username attached to a report, so you don’t have to worry about going on some sort of secret reporter list reports are always anonymous and treated as confidential, even if you modmail us directly.

Two things that are not helpful, however, are a) when users downvote obvious rules-breaking posts but don't report them or b) when users respond with something like "Just wait till the Mods show up!" but don't report. If a post is worth downvoting, it is probably worth reporting. If the only response a post deserves is derisive, it is probably worth reporting.

In the case of the latter, this is actually a great disservice to everyone. I know everyone is familiar by now with the occasional sea of [deleted]. What you might not know is that a deleted or removed comment only displays that if the comment had a response! So if you see a comment you know will be removed, replying to it is a direct cause of thread clutter even after removal! Simply reporting it and letting us remove it before it garners any responses helps to keep threads cleaner!

If you’re wondering what happens on our end, this is what it looks like. We hit the remove button and then jump into the thread to issue warnings and bannings as needed!

So as always, thank you for your participation and your reading of the sub and I hope this post encourages you to help us help you…or something to that effect. Let me know if you have any questions in the comments below!

TheBulgarSlayer

One amazing trick

Trolls hate him!

iorgfeflkd

Can I leave silly comments underneath mod comments?

Like if you lay down a rule smackdown beneath a comment you deleted, can I comment on how much of a smackdown it was?

joneSee

HYPOTHETICAL PERSON

TIL I am not reals. But, but... I have so many feels!

Crassusinyourasses

How does one report on alien blue?

ngwoo

I'll report every post to make sure I get all the bad ones!

atyon

I'd like to use this opportunity to say that I don't like the current selection in the report widget very much. They seem inconsistent and a little clumsy.

My specific gripes:

  • Violates Submission Rules (Trivia/Poll/HomeWk/Etc): This is unnecessary verbose. We already established that a rule is being broken. "Trivia, polls, homework or what-if-questions" would need no abbreviations. It includes the most relevant cases and has just 43 characters.
  • Slashes / or. Pick one. I would prefer or, but / everywhere is better than the inconcistency.
  • Incivility or rudeness vs. Bigotry/racism. Do you need both? I might have a heard time distinguishing between these.
  • Soapboxing/Modern Politics/Sub-20 Year Discussion. This is mess. I don't have a good alternative, but maybe after joining the last two rules I mentioned you can split this in two, and have "Discussion of recent events (last 20 years)" and "Soapboxing, moralising or political discussion". Or a better version of the latter.
  • Just/Mostly a Link or Quote. Why not just "Mostly a link or quote"?

Ceterum censeo that I don't like title capitalization. It's also not used in the reddit-rules-dropdown and the rest of the widget, so looks a bit out of place.

All that said, this is complaining on a very high level. You're moderation itself is very good!

DoctorWhoToYou

When a user gets a comment deleted. Do they know it's deleted? Does it show up as [comment removed] in the thread, or do they continue to see their own comment in the thread?

101189

This place. Improving what you already do well. Here's a trophy for most deleted comments all time. I see so many deleted comments I don't scroll past the first one anymore when I'm in this subreddit.

eternalkerri

When I first logged in this morning and saw vertexoflife's reply to my post, I was genuinely like, "WTF, Mate?" and I'm not even English.

i_pewpewpew_you

Here's a question, I responded to / refuted an answer the other day because it was unsourced rubbish. Sadly, I was at work, so wasn't able to add any sources in my refutation so basically it was just anecdotal evidence I could provide. Better to just report the answer, in that case?

Akasazh

I'd like to see a graph from the reasons this post got reported. That's all :). Cheers for being sifters of the comment gold from the comment poopoo.

Ramp_Rat

What's the rules on reporting flaired users?

Or are they untouchable, and irrefutable here, as I have been led to believe by the actions of the mod team?

never__surrender

Gotta love a nice hug-box.