What was Emperor Hirhohito not considered a war criminal once the Allies won?

by badboyfriend111
OldWorldGlory

You may be interested in past posts on this topic:

For followup questions, use username mentions in this thread to direct questions to specific commenters.

NFB42

Short answer: Because McArthur personally and through him the American occupiers in general believed in keeping the Emperor clear of blame and using the Emperor as a source of stability and legitimisation of the new constitutional democratic order.

Contrary to what some of the unsourced replies here are saying, this was not an objective opinion nor something broadly shared by everyone involved. There were and still are those who seriously question this move and who believe at the very least the Emperor ought to have been made to abdicate as a way of accepting culpability for not just the war with the US but the entire era of militarism leading up to it. Examples are historians John Dower and Herbert Bix.

For further reading I recommend the comments linked by /u/OldWorldGlory, and Embracing Defeat by John Dower.

Orlando1701

It came down to two questions at the end of the war, 1) what was his actual role in conducting the war. Was he a figurehead, an icon with the general staff actually calling the shots or was he actually involved in the strategy of the war. 2) Post war the US needed him, they needed him to validate the US occupation and to provide continuity of leadership with the general population. Most modern historians feel that he was wholly removed from the tactical level in the war and even at the strategic level had very little input, indeed when he announced the surrender of Japan there were segments of the Army which fought back and tried to block his announcement that Japan would surrender. Post war MacAurther knew he'd need him in the rebuilding process and to get the Japanese government and society working again, Japan was utterly decimated at the end of the war.

TL;DR - it's not clear he really had much to do with the war and the US needed him after the war.