Why did the flat top helmet become popular in the high middle ages?

by Frank23682

I'm under the impression that the nasal helmet evolved into the flat topped helmet in the high middle ages. However, from a pure protection perspective, it seems like the nasal helmet's round top design would be able to deflect overhead blows while the flat top design would just stop whatever weapon swung at it and absorb the force entirely, causing more injury to the wearer.

So why did flat top helmets become so popular?

KNHaw

No one has commented, so I will add some speculation from an engineering/manufacturing standpoint.

Flat topped helmets would be easier to make if metal is accessible in thick sheets. Instead of hammering out a more complex concave shape like a bowl, one can form most pieces with metal rolling equipment and then rivet the parts together. If an armorer already had to flatten their own stock by hand, though, then curving it into a desired final state is not an appreciably longer process.

Now, did their rise of flat top helmets coincide with the advent of sheet metal and metal rolling technology? I honestly have no idea. I would love to hear any alternative thoughts, though.