What is the professional opinion of Victor Davis Hanson?

by GreensburgZombie

I've just re-read Carnage and Culture - and though it is unabashedly ethnocentric, it seems to make good points about the value of discipline and decisive battle in the history of the spread of Western civilization. Are there any major criticisms out there?

agentdcf

Hi there! This question was recently discussed, here and here, by one of our resident experts (this user has also been featured on our podcast, check it out!). This should not prevent further discussion, of course, but you might find what you're looking for there.