Early Mesopotamian civilizations are described as lasting for ridiculously long amounts of time while more modern states tend to rarely last longer than 300 years. Why are these early states so stable?

by Xxxn00bpwnR69xxX
isleepinahammock

Do you have some examples of what precisely you mean by "a ridiculously long time?" Are these examples of specific states or dynasties, or just from archaeological documentation of a city existing at a site? A lot of this may come down to how precisely you define a "civilization." For instance, look at modern Germany or France. You can trace the current German or French people and culture back a thousand years, but the nations have undergone numerous changes in government, territorial boundaries, etc. When an early Mesopotamian civilization is listed as lasting for a similar length of time, the source may be using similar broad strokes as saying, "the French culture has existed for over a thousand years."