Was the focus on the Law of Homogeneity an obstacle for mathematicians?

by vikes28

In relating to algebra, The law of homogeneity was the notion that all terms in a given equation must be of the same degree.

  • Many ancient Greek mathematicians stuck to this belief.
  • Islamic Mathematician, Ibn Al-Baghdadi(990-1037?) did not
  • Francoi Viete (1540-1603) stuck to the belief
  • Rene Descartes (1596-1640) not so much

My question is: Was mathematicians' focus on this law an obstacle for the development of algebraic reasoning?

CubicZircon

Mathematician here; I don't even know what you are speaking about. There have always been homogeneous and inhomogeneous equations, treated somewhat differently (because solutions of homogeneous equations are stable under dilation). So I highly suspect your premise to be completely wrong (there has never been such a thing as a Law of Homogeneity). For one thing, Viète was instrumental in solving the third- and fourth-degree polynomial equations, which are decidedly inhomogeneous.

What might have hampered somewhat mathematicians is the lack of abstraction: i.e. needing to represent all quantities in an equation as lengths or surfaces, etc. However, the progress of abstraction and notation was quite parallel to the progress of techniques (see the apparition of Arabic digits in the 13th century, the + and - signs in the 15th, the = sign and abstract variables in the 16th, and powers in the 17th and 18th centuries).