Friday Free-for-All | January 27, 2017

by AutoModerator

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

the_howling_cow

I recently finished parsing out the production of the B-26C, produced from August 1942 to April 1944 at Martin's subsidiary plant in Omaha, Nebraska.

Month Number built Model Serial numbers Modification from previous variant
August 1942 3 B-26C-5-MO 41-34673 to 41-34675
September 1942 7 B-26C-5-MO 41-34676 to 41-346780, 41-346782, 41-346783
October 1942 11 B-26C-5-MO 41-346784 to 41-346788, 41-34694 to 41-34696, 41-34700, 41-34701
November 1942 15 B-26C-5-MO 41-34743 to 41-34757
December 1942 50 B-26C-5-MO 41-34758 to 41-34776, 41-34788 to 41-34818
January 1943 29 B-26C-5-MO 41-34819 to 41-34847
January 1943 1 B-26C-6-MO 41-34681 Copilot deleted as weight reduction measure; later restored after combat experience
February 1943 50 B-26C-6-MO 41-34689 to 41-34693, 41-34695, 41-34702 to 41-34742, 41-34777 to 41-34779
March 1943 8 B-26C-6-MO 41-34780 to 41-34787
March 1943 60 B-26C-10-MO 41-34848 to 41-34907 Martin's Omaha plant made required changes, and the B-26C was now fully identical to the B-26B
March 1943 2 B-26C-15-MO 41-34908 to 41-34909 A-9 oxygen regulator deleted and SCR-595A IFF set fitted
April 1943 88 B-26C-15-MO 41-34910 to 41-34997
April 1943 2 B-26C-20-MO 41-34998, 41-34999 Bell M-6 power-operated tail turret and shorter-chord rudder fitted
May 1943 110 B-26C-20-MO 41-35000 to 41-35109
June 1943 63 B-26C-20-MO 41-35110 to 41-35172
June 1943 62 B-26C-25-MO 41-35173 to 41-35234 Additional armor plate on tail turret; tail gun shell collector pan fitted to MTO-bound aircraft; 41-35370 to 41-35372 (3) converted to AT-23B
July 1943 125 B-26C-25-MO 41-35235 to 41-35359
August 1943 13 B-26C-25-MO 41-35360 to 41-35372
August 1943 132 B-26C-30-MO 41-35373 to 41-35504 Additional armor plate added to pilot's and bombardier's cabin; 41-35525 to 41-35572 (48) converted to AT-23B; 100 C-30 to RAF as Marauder Mk. II FB 418-517
September 1943 68 B-26C-30-MO 41-35505 to 41-35572
September 1943 67 B-26C-30-MO 41-35573 to 41-35639
October 1943 125 B-26C-35-MO 41-35640 to 41-35764 Carburetor de-icer deleted; 41-35598 to 41-35620 (23) converted to AT-23B
November 1943 8 B-26C-35-MO 41-35765 to 41-35772
November 1943 100 B-26C-40-MO (AT-23B) 41-35773 to 41-35872 Torpedo firing switch added to pilot's control column and B-2 torpedo director deleted; all converted to AT-23B
November 1943 2 B-26C-45-MO 42-107497 to 42-107498 Ring and bead sight for package guns; increased strength bomb hooks for B-10 shackles; rear bomb bay sealed up; engine fire extinguisher reinstated; SCR-695 IFF set and SCR-522 command radio added
December 1943 100 B-26C-45-MO 42-107499 to 42-107598
January 1944 90 B-26C-45-MO 42-107599 to 42-107688
February 1944 83 B-26C-45-MO 42-107689 to 42-107771
March 1944 70 B-26C-45-MO 42-107772 to 42-107841
April 1944 14 (15?) B-26C-45-MO 42-107842 to 42-107855
April 1944 26 AT-23B 42-107856 to 42-107881
uniofreading

One of our Classics Professors has a new free online course coming out which might be interesting: http://rdg.ac/FLvirtualrome

He's using his own award-winning virtual model of ancient Rome to show what the city would have been like at its peak, and to try and answer some common questions:

Why was this ancient city built where it was? Did all roads really lead to Rome? How was drinking water supplied to the city’s million inhabitants? Where did Romans worship their gods and meet their political masters? And which buildings provided a backdrop for the spectacular events that both celebrated emperors and secured the loyalty of the masses?

He's also keen to take part in an AMA, so let us know if you're interested in talking to him here in the community!

Tim - University of Reading

Shashank1000

I managed to read a vast and excellent study on the economic history of Finland from 1860 to 1990 written by a Ritta Hjerppe and published by Bank of Finland.

Another was the comparative study done by European Union on the tax structure and fiscal policy of all the member States. Well, let's just say that the economic prospects for European countries are not good. On the other hand it also provided evidence from France that how property taxes can work towards reducing risks of Property bubble while collecting quite a lot of tax revenue.

Third one was a white paper published by the authors of the book "Rescuing Retirement" written by Teresa Ghilarducci who was with the left leaning think tank 'Economic Policy Institute' and Hamilton James who was with the asset management company Black Rock on proposals to reform the retirement saving system in the US (which is currently a disaster waiting to happen).

chikindiner

I decided to read this in tandem with 1491 so I can write Mann angry letters when I catch him shilling for Big Archaeology. Thoughts?

Also, what's a good follow up to 1491?

AncientHistory

I received a copy of Chris Bishop's Medievalist Comics in the American Century, which looks at the theme of "medievalist" comics - taking as particular examples of close study Prince Valiant, Green Arrow, Conan the Barbarian, etc. as American comics seized on these "medieval" archetypes of knights, archers, and swordsmen as heroes in the 20th century. From page 29:

By the time Hearst had acquired the rights to publish Prince Valiant, he could already lay claim to a sizable collection of medieval objects. Hearst reputedly possessed the world's largest private collection of medieval armor, far outstripping his nearest rivals the industrialist Henry Ford and the banker Andrew Mellon.

This reminded me of Bashford Dean's Helmets and Body Armor in Modern Warfare - Dean was associated with the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York City, and was a noted collector and cataloguer of arms and armor; his book, published during WWI, shows clearly how contemporary minds were struggling to come to terms with the change in technology and tactics - trench warfare really being a throwback to siege warfare, swords rapidly obsolete as side-arms but still present (as were bayonets), and in this book Dean focuses on the design and effectiveness of personal body armor, helmets, and shields, noting their forebears in medieval forms. There, Dean noted that Ford was a notable manufacturer of helmets for World War I, and writes on page 212:

Thus, in the summer of 1917, this helmet, after having been shown to the experts of several manufacturing ocncerns, who feared that it could not be made, was turned over to teh Worcester Pressed Steel Company with directions to produce it in an experimental lot in 12 per cent manganese steel. Dies accordingly were prepared and every effort was made to deliver the helmets needed. Ufnortunately, however, the dies which this firm employed were inadequately designed and in the end the only helmets produced were defective, having their sides wrinkled and their tops thinned out. Later, however, this helmet was shown to Messrs. Ford and Company of Detroit who declared that it could be pressed and pressed well without an important breakage of metal. Accordingly, this firm, receivne an order from the Ordnance Department, produced a set of experimental dies. On these, during the fall of 1918, a couple of thousand helmets were turned out. It may be mentioned that the principle upon which Messrs Ford and Company proceeded was quite similar to that which an armorer would have used in olden times, for the top of the helmet was pressed not as a final but as an earlier operation.

This in turn reminded me of a bit of verse from Robert E. Howard's letters - Howard being the creator of Conan the Barbarian, and an early and incredibly influential writer in the genre of Sword & Sorcery fiction, had a great interest in arms and armor, including a modest collection of swords (most of them being American military swords) - but this "medievalist" aesthetic was always contrast against what he saw as contemporary civilization, as when he wrote:

L'Envoi

Now flapper ridden flivvers whiz

Along the ancient road.

An Armours packinghouse does biz

Where once King Bahthur strode.

Bootleggers slink along the paths

Where knights kissed ladies’ hands,

Where shield crashed shield in tourney great

A filling station stands.

Centuries gone, those noble knights,

Forgot, their helmets rust,

Yet in their homage let us sing,

“Flourish the packing trust!”

  • Robert E. Howard to Tevis Clyde Smith, date unknown, but ca. before July 1925, Collected Letters of Robert E. Howard 3.469

Which is a long way to not doing anything productive, just following some tangents I found interesting.

freedmenspatrol

Managed to get some writing done on a much overdue answer about Nullification which has slowly grown into "explain everything about the Nullification crisis while rereading the major text and some important papers". It's not done yet, but I am up to 1829.

It's coming, OP. I promise.

Anon4comment

Can any historian tell me if Indian history is really interesting, but just poorly researched? Sometimes it seems to me as an Indian that we don't have as compelling a founding myth as the Americans, Europeans and the Chinese. Yes I know about the Mahabharata and the Ramayana, but still: why is Chinese history so much better known than Indian history? I'm sure we made some technological advancements and great discoveries too. Many Indians I meet claim India in the past was the wealthiest country in the world. I don't see this claim gaining support from any western sources. Sorry, I don't think this merits a full thread. Maybe I'm just envious.

caffarelli

A new Farinelli-themed recital album is coming out in February! Amusingly, The Guardian's review makes it sound like a CD of fart sounts. I look forward to ripping one... off of the library holds shelf... when this comes out.

chocolatepot

Today I'm working on accessioning photographs that have been found in the collection, which is honestly one of the things I like the most about my job. Partly because trying to figure out who all the sitters are, to connect the genealogical dots, etc. is a good puzzle, but also because there's something satisfying in making sure that this person who lived in their hometown their whole life and never did anything "important" is still known and remembered. It's also a great way to learn about local families and schools and other social groups without sitting down to go, "Okay, I work at the county historical association, I need to know all of the country schools."

(I'm weirdly enthralled by country schools. I want to do an exhibition on them this year.)

kiwiinacup

I wasn't sure where to turn but I need help identifying someone on a shirt. I'm so sorry for the potato quality! Thank you again!

http://imgur.com/GIneoJe

StatisticallyDeviant

What documentaries have people been watching here? I'm a history noob but I'm looking for history documentaries that have a high degree of accuracy/correctness and I'd love to read some suggestions.

walker6168

I'm working on a historical fiction book set in Reconstruction South about the founding of a University in Appalachia. The book is on its fourth draft and I was hoping to maybe swap critiques with a historian familiar with the time period.

I've read a ton of books about the time period but I'm a lawyer by day. I worked as an editor and freelance writer for years before law school, the book is just a side project.

I can link to some of my other stuff, the only other thing that qualifies as historical fiction is an HP Lovecraft homage set in 1830 on a plantation. Here's the link.

Happy to be a test reader for any kind of book in exchange, or maybe even proof a thesis. I'm used to long, technical reads.

[deleted]

Are there any other pop history authors as good as Barbara Tuchman? I don't know why but her style of writing is really enjoyable.

j_gu

I'm launching a site where you can answer with data visualizations in addition to regular text.

Here are examples where I think the idea is illustrated well: https://graphme.io/t/how-did-germany-utilize-its-armies-in-the-battle-of-the-bulge/108/2 https://graphme.io/t/where-were-and-how-powerful-were-the-worlds-nuclear-bomb-tests/99/2

mweuste

Can anyone recommend any books in English on the migration era and steppe cultures like the Xiongnu?

BlackendLight

Any information on the bagaudae?

Gunlord500

Not much to report for this week...cause, thankfully, my profs gave me an extension! My second draft is now due on February 3. I coulda gotten it out by the 29th, but the extra 5 days lets me polish it up a little 8)

changement

Hi everyone, I have been looking for a specific book that I can't recall the title of, and I am hoping someone here can identify it or recommend something similar on the topic.

The topic of the book was the American Civil War and I read an excerpt from the introduction along with a positive review in (probably??) either the NY Times or the Washington Post, probably around 2008-2009ish? The excerpt described how at the beginning of the Civil War, two escaped slaves took refuge with some Union soldiers, expecting to be protected by them, but the Union soldiers were unsure of what to do with them, because at the time the Union had not explicitly chosen to be absolutely against slavery. The book chronicled the political progress on the Union side leading to that point and to the Emancipation Proclamation. It sounded very interesting but I am pretty sure I read this when I was in grad school (not for history!) and didn't have time to read it.

If anyone knows what book I am talking about OR can another book on the topic of progression of Union political thought on slavery, I would greatly appreciate it.

(It's possible I've gotten some details wrong because I have honestly looked for this book pretty seriously already and I can't understand how it's so hard to find a book I read excerpted in a major newspaper within the last decade......???)