How accurate/scholarly is the "Stuff You Missed in History Class" podcast?

by Throbbing_Smarton

I was hoping somebody more learned than I can give me a general idea of how reliable the information presented in "Stuff You Missed in History Class" is.

I haven't always been so pleased with the productions from How Stuff Works when they wander into my areas of expertise, so I'm a bit skeptical of their "Stuff You Missed in History Class" podcast. Unfortunately, history is not an area in which I have much knowledge, so they could be telling me all kinds of non-evidence-supported hearsay, and I wouldn't know the difference.^(†) Now, I don't expect an episode-by-episode breakdown, certainly, but a general idea of how reliable they are would be appreciated. Can I take everything they say at face value? Should I generally accept their assertions, but with a grain of salt? Or is the quality low and unscholarly enough such that I should just pass on the podcast altogether?

Bonus Question: Any other, specific recommendations for high-quality, evidence-based history podcasts?

Thanks for your input on this particular matter, but also for your collective commitment to academic rigor in general; this place has become my go-to for history-related inquiries solely because I know I can place a high degree of confidence in the community's responses.


^^† ^(To my chagrin, that actually happened to me with Dan Carlin's stuff; I listened to nearly all of his podcasts before learning that his factual accuracy can be...spotty. Now, I can only wonder how much of the information I assimilated is flawed, or just straight up wrong. It's a bad feeling, and I'd like to avoid that in the future.)

RoyalRebel85

In regards to the second question, have you tried BBC's In Our Time with Melvyn Bragg? It's not strictly a history podcast, but he brings on three experts (usually professors) to discuss a topic. The topics are discussed in a more academic manner (as best as you can get with the podcast format)

If you're interested in Tudor/Stuart Ireland, there's a "podcast" that features all of the delivered papers from the annual conference at the National University of Ireland in Galway.

Hopefully those work for you!

Searocksandtrees

Bonus Question: Any other, specific recommendations for high-quality, evidence-based history podcasts?

Did you know that this subreddit produces its own podcast? It's biweekly; the format is typically a 1-on-1 interview with an expert, who is often a flaired user from this subreddit, but may be a visiting guest. Check it out - https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/wiki/podcast