I was hoping somebody more learned than I can give me a general idea of how reliable the information presented in "Stuff You Missed in History Class" is.
I haven't always been so pleased with the productions from How Stuff Works when they wander into my areas of expertise, so I'm a bit skeptical of their "Stuff You Missed in History Class" podcast. Unfortunately, history is not an area in which I have much knowledge, so they could be telling me all kinds of non-evidence-supported hearsay, and I wouldn't know the difference.^(†) Now, I don't expect an episode-by-episode breakdown, certainly, but a general idea of how reliable they are would be appreciated. Can I take everything they say at face value? Should I generally accept their assertions, but with a grain of salt? Or is the quality low and unscholarly enough such that I should just pass on the podcast altogether?
Bonus Question: Any other, specific recommendations for high-quality, evidence-based history podcasts?
Thanks for your input on this particular matter, but also for your collective commitment to academic rigor in general; this place has become my go-to for history-related inquiries solely because I know I can place a high degree of confidence in the community's responses.
^^† ^(To my chagrin, that actually happened to me with Dan Carlin's stuff; I listened to nearly all of his podcasts before learning that his factual accuracy can be...spotty. Now, I can only wonder how much of the information I assimilated is flawed, or just straight up wrong. It's a bad feeling, and I'd like to avoid that in the future.)
In regards to the second question, have you tried BBC's In Our Time with Melvyn Bragg? It's not strictly a history podcast, but he brings on three experts (usually professors) to discuss a topic. The topics are discussed in a more academic manner (as best as you can get with the podcast format)
If you're interested in Tudor/Stuart Ireland, there's a "podcast" that features all of the delivered papers from the annual conference at the National University of Ireland in Galway.
Hopefully those work for you!
Bonus Question: Any other, specific recommendations for high-quality, evidence-based history podcasts?
Did you know that this subreddit produces its own podcast? It's biweekly; the format is typically a 1-on-1 interview with an expert, who is often a flaired user from this subreddit, but may be a visiting guest. Check it out - https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/wiki/podcast