Were kings sole overlords? Or could dukes collect taxes and order counts/barons around?

by AlterOfYume

Hello, I would like to learn more about the hierarchy of power and distribution of land in medieval kingdoms. While I understand that barons are lower than counts, who are in turn lower than dukes, what was the exact relationship between these ranks?

Did duchies contain several counties? And were counties made up of baronies? Did a count have a sovereign duke he must obey because of where his territory was located?

Or were all of these provinces just considered "independent" fiefs of different sizes, and nobles were only required to pay tribute and obey the king?

I would also like to know more about what usually happened to non-heir children, not just in the royal family but also in other noble ranks. Thank you in advance.

deMohac

The middle ages span a millennium and during that period there was significant diversity in taxation and political structures across Europe. You may want to post the question again, narrowing the time and space you are interested in.

In the eleventh century, for example, you had the Byzantine Empire that still used (very successfully) the land-based taxation system of the Roman Empire, and was able to use the steady, fairly reliable income to keep a standing army and maintain infrastructure. You would have a hierarchy with the emperor at the top and local government administrators collecting taxes at the bottom. On the other end, you have western Europe where taxation was an occasional thing only activated at times of war and crusades. Kings tended to have relatively weak power. In France, for example, the king would nominally rule over all of France, but in reality would only control a small area centered around Paris. The rest of the country was in the hands of regional lords, who nominally ruled over their region but, again, usually only had real power over a small portion of it. Power was mostly in the hands of local barons, who controlled the local economy and justice system. Two centuries later, after the Albigensian crusade in the south and wars with England in the west, power in France was more centralized and the local level had been replaced with bureaucrats appointed by the crown. By then taxation was becoming a more regular occurrence in France.