Why are Asians displayed with the swap of R for L in English, when it's the opposite (L for R) on some Languages (like German)?

by maldofel

Despite being the same languages, Japanese, Chinese and other Asian languages are differently used (or have different characteristics) in caricatures in various Countries. Why is this so?

ivymikey

This is a better question for /r/linguistics, but the basic rundown is that /l/ and /r/ are liquid consonants and English just so happens to use both of them. Korean only has the single ㄹ sound which is in the middle of the two sounds. The result is that Koreans will frequently mix the two sounds up, especially if they learn English through reading - the words "rob" and "lob" would both be written as 랍 or 롭, depending on which vowel sound you want to use. German has different phonology and as a result has a different shift of sound.

It should be noted that Japanese, Chinese, and Korean have different phonological rules and as such cause different problems for English L2 speakers. In Korean, the l/r sound can change based on the location in the word. A word that starts with the sound is generally neutral, while a word like 나라, (nara - earth)where the /r/ sound is on the second syllable sounds like an /r/. A word like 전라도 (Jeolla-do, a province) has more of an /l/ sound. In Chinese, they have the opposite issue.

Anyway, unless you want a history of Asian language romanization and how sound representations have changed, go to /r/linguistics for a better answer.

The_Manchurian

I'm not 100% sure I understand your question: Are you asking "why do English people stereotype Asians as pronouncing L as R when speaking English, whereas Germans stereotype Asians as pronouncing R as L when speaking German?"