Were german (battle-)ships in WW2 really as resilent as there reputation says?

by Pashahlis

Both Bismarck and Tirpitz endured ALOT of damage before sinking. Thus german battleships have the reputation of being extremely resilent and armoured. Is this true or just a popular myth? What made them so resilent?

jschooltiger

Not discouraging further answers, but: The Bismarck's design was really quite bad -- you may be interested in this older thread where u/DBHT14 and u/thefourthmaninaboat discuss the ship's design flaws. (Tirpitz spent its career at anchor, so its fighting qualities were never tested.)

Since that thread is archived, feel free to ask follow-up questions here.