The Indian subcontinent would be referring to the countries of India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Maldives, and maybe Bhutan.
To me, it seems to me like this region has all the necessary element needed to count as a continent.
In fact, I think it has a better claim as a continent than Europe, since the Indian subcontinent actually used to be its own continent when it detached from Africa.
This might be something to X-post to /r/AskScience, as it also speaks to non-historical concerns which they can address.