During the Korean war, how was the evacuation of Hungnam achieved with so few American casualties?

by Reasonabledwarf

There is strangely little popular media of any kind about the Korean war, and what there is tends to be either contemporary and jingoistic, or extremely broad and highly generalized. I was recently surprised to learn that, during the Chinese counterattack that ejected UN forces from North Korea, significant elements of the American forces and tens of thousands of civilian refugees were surrounded in the port of Hungnam by the Chinese army.

Instead of being captured or destroyed, literally all American forces escaped over the course of a 1-2 week naval evacuation, along with a significant amount of civilian refugees, and all their equipment. The numbers approach those of the battle of Dunkirk in terms of manpower and time pressure (and exceed it in materiel), but the casualties differ wildly: at Hungnam, almost no American casualties are recorded in the writing I can find (2 men were killed and roughly twenty wounded in an accidental explosion).

My question is, why were casualties during this action so light? Were Chinese forces focused on containment, or on pushing towards Seoul? Was the American artillery and air support capable of holding off Chinese forces indefinitely? Were Chinese units under orders to consolidate their position, or wait for reinforcements? It seems to me that, considering the Chinese tactic of mass infantry charges in use at the time, a push through the American artillery curtain wouldn't have been out of the question.

ivymikey

The Hungnam evacuation is a footnote to the larger Battle of Chosin Reservoir. The battle occurred about 15 miles away, high in the mountains. The Chinese forces surrounded an outnumbered X Corps and attacked. The battle was a victory for the Chinese but at extreme cost - their forces were severely injured and they were not a fully capable fighting force until the next spring.

Once the US forces pulled out of Chosin, they had to navigate a long, steep, and narrow canyon road back to Hungnam. The Chinese attempted to follow and continue the attack but they were in no position to do so. Their forces had taken many casualties, the weather was harsh, and (most importantly), the US Navy was stationed off the coast of North Korea and was able to lay down impressive fire that the Chinese could not counter or bypass. Once the US forces were within the protective umbrella of the naval guns, the Chinese couldn't do anything.

It's important to view the evacuation of Hungnam as a part of the larger battle at Chosin. While the evacuation itself was flawless, there were nearly 18,000 US casualties during that campaign, including nearly 5,000 MIA, many of whom are probably still laying around the reservoir to this day. The evacuation itself, especially the SS Meredith Victory's record setting load, has always been played up as a shining example as a way to... soften the blow?... of what had happened immediately prior.