Why was the first German Kaiser proclaimed in the palace of Versailles rather than somewhere in Germany?

by omarcomin647

I know Paris was under siege at the time, but I can't find an answer as to why such an important event for the German Empire would be held on foreign soil. Was it simply meant to be a symbol of the defeat of France?

kieslowskifan

From an earlier answer of mine

While it is tempting to ascribe Bismarck's motivation for the declaration in the Hall of Mirrors solely to humiliation of the Erbfeind France, there were domestic considerations at play in the location choice of Versailles. This was clear in the patterns of invitations and the behind-the-scenes maneuvering Bismarck conducted in the lead up to the proclamation of the Empire.

There were two crucial facets of German history that would have been on Bismarck's mind given his experience and subsequent actions. One, there already had been an offer of a German crown made to the Hohenzollern monarch, Wilhelm I's brother King Frederick Wilhelm IV, by the Frankfurt Paulskirche parliament in the Revolution of 1848. The Prussian King refused and Bismarck had been part of the counter-revolution that squashed the Paulskirche liberals. Although older historiography stressed the defeat of German liberals in 1848- A.J.P. Taylor famously termed it a turning point that failed to turn- recent research into German liberalism has shown it was surprisingly active post-1848 and was one of Bismarck's political rivals. His tussles with the Prussian Diet in the 1860s over the Landwehr issue had shown that while he was an adept parliamentary leader, there still was an organized opposition within Germany among its various elected bodies.

Secondly, Bismarck was also acutely aware that not all of the German princes were in favor of a Hohenzollern hegemony in the new Germany. The negotiations with the southern German monarchs for the imminent declaration of the German empire as German operations continued against the French had been quite tense. Bismarck had to alternate between threats and bribery to ensure that these monarchs would fall in line when the time came. The Prussian Chancellor also had to contend with the reluctance of his regal master, Wilhelm I who tended to be indifferent to the issue of his future imperial title. Bismarck also cajoled the reluctant Wittelsbach monarch to appeal to Wilhelm I to accept the German crown since Wilhelm I would accept the crown from a fellow monarch, not his subjects.

Therefore it made a degree of sense to hold the declaration of the Empire in Versailles. Having a German-based declaration opened up two thorny and interrelated issues: where to hold such a declaration and the possibility of Bismarck losing control over a delicate situation. Had the Empire been declared in Berlin or Potsdam, it might alter the fragile consensus among the southern German monarchs for the Empire by emphasizing Hohenzollern and Prussian supremacy too much. A ceremony in the North German Reichstag would be a recapitulation of 1848 and cede too much symbolic power to the elected body. Bismarck's constitution had already tried to limit the power of the Reichstag and it was against Bismarck's own political instincts to give them the high ground (a stubbornness that was the source of no end of troubles as Chancellor). Delaying for a suitable German declaration spot would open up the possibility that other individuals like the Prussian Crown Prince or the National Liberals could influence the tractable Wilhelm I. Having the various monarchs travel to Versailles was a way to compel a degree of supplication to the new power arrangement in German affairs. Moreover, the ceremony of the various German monarchs proclaiming Wilhelm Kaiser also sent a message that the new federal entity was based on a union of monarchs. The Reichstag was supposed to accept this as a fait accompli and as subordinate partners to their respective monarchs. Notably absent from the Hall of Mirrors was a delegation from North German Reichstag. Although some individual parliamentary leaders attended the ceremony, attempts to have the delegation meet at Versailles were rebuffed on the grounds of logistics and that a number of parliamentarians found the idea quite baroque.

While there is no doubt that using Versailles had the bonus of humiliating the French and being a symbol of reversing history, there were other motives at play in Bismarck's decision process in addition to revenge. Versailles's location was convenient as many of the crowned heads and generals were already in France, but this expediency was a means not an end onto itself. By making the future subordinates come to Wilhelm I, and by extension, his Chancellor, the ceremony was sending a clear message of political power. Yet these power games did not exactly thrill Bismarck; most commentators noted that he was miserable during the ceremony and he wrote back to his wife he was constantly frustrated having to deal with so many different problems in his role as the midwife to unification.

Sources

Lerman, Katharine Anne. Bismarck. London [u.a.]: Routledge, 2014.

Pflanze, Otto. Bismarck and the Development of Germany, Volume 1. Princeton: Princeton Univ. Press, 1971.

Steinberg, Jonathan. Bismarck: A Life. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013.