Was Hitler completely responsible for the Final Solution?

by ow2n

Since the Nazi administration revolved around Hitler's deputies acting based on their interpretation of the "Fuhrer's Will", did his deputies (e.g. Himmler and Heydrich) persecute the Jews more than what Hitler had in mind?

Furthermore, were there instances of mass persecution/extermination during the implementation of the Final Solution which Hitler was unaware of/ not responsible?

I thought of this question after reading this excerpt from "Hitler's War" by David Irving:

"In October , even as Himmler was disclosing to privileged audiences of SS generals and gauleiters that Europe’s Jews had been systematically murdered, Hitler was still forbidding liquidations – e.g., of the Italian Jews in Rome – and ordering their internment instead. (This order his SS also disobeyed.) In July , overriding Himmler’s objections, he ordered that Jews be bartered for foreign currency or supplies; there is some evidence that like contemporary terrorists he saw these captives as a potential asset, a means whereby he could blackmail his enemies. Wholly in keeping with his character, when Hitler was confronted with the facts he took no action to rebuke the guilty; he would not dismiss Himmler as Reichsführer SS until the last day of his life."

Thank you! If I have missed out anything important, please let me know (This is my first post on this sub)

Elm11

Hi there,

Not to preclude further discussion, but you may be interested in the following answers regarding Hitler's involvement in the Holocaust, largely by /u/commiespaceinvader:

In addition, you should be aware that Hitler's War has been comprehensively debunked as a serious historical work, and demonstrated to be a misleading, dishonest, extremist work. To that end, you should be extremely suspicious of any claims which it makes, including its use of quotes and documents, which have been demonstrated to be riddled with forgeries and inaccuracies. David Irving is himself a conspiracy theorist, a racist and a Holocaust denier, and you can find discussions about him here, here and in our excellent Monday Methods piece on Holocaust denialism here.