Can someone elaborate on what FDR is referring to in his famous Infamy Speech after Pearl Harbor when he says: ”...and, at the solicitation of Japan, still in conversation toward the maintenance of peace in the Pacific.” Is FDR saying Japan initiated these talks and exactly what was he refering to?

by Jagdgeschwader

Particularly it is the part about "at the solicitation of Japan" that I am confused over.

The full quote is:

The United States was at peace with that nation and, at the solicitation of Japan, was still in conversation with its government and its emperor looking toward the maintenance of peace in the Pacific.

With the context of the speech he is obviously trying to emphasize the treachery of the attacks, but I'm not entirely sure what he means by "and, at the solicitation of Japan,". Is he saying that Japan themselves initiated this peace discussion (which if this is the case it is something I am not familiar with and was hoping someone could provide explanation), or simply that "we [America] were still trying to hold discussions with Japan"?

Immediately after in the speech he talks about how Japan had recently replied to an American message saying that "it seemed useless to continue the existing diplomatic negotiations", which sort of seems contradictory to the first one (that Japan was responsible for trying to continue discussions), but I'm kind of confused by the wording.

Here is a link to the full speech for context: https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Pearl_Harbor_speech

kieslowskifan

Is he saying that Japan themselves initiated this peace discussion?

More or less. The Japanese Foreign Ministry had dispatched the IJN admiral Nomura Kichisaburō in November 1940 with the specific task of trying to smooth over US-Japanese relations. Kurusu Saburō joined Nomura as a special envoy in November 1941 to try and help to deescalate the growing tensions over Japan's continued war in China, its Tripartite Pact with Germany and Italy, as well as Japanese moves towards French Indochina. Both men were relative doves within the Japanese government and were aligned with the more cautious approach to foreign relations exemplified by Japanese PM Konoe Fumimaro. Both envoys dealt with US Secretary of State Cordell Hull and Japan's stated purpose of this diplomatic mission was to avoid war and preserve peace in the Pacific.

While FDR was certainly presenting a very one-sided view of the Kurusu-Nomura negotiations in his speech. Japan was not the sole initiator of these talks and Hull certainly did his part in making sure that they broke down. The general US demands were for a suspension of the war in China, Japan's breaking or loosening of the Tripartite Pact, and guarantees of Japan not to seize territory in the Pacific. These were not necessarily unreasonable goals on the part of the US but they were also ones that the divided Japanese government could never meet. Konoye's successor, Army Minister Tōjō Hideki, was not a man who could ever meet these demands as he was expansionist and a firm believer in the China war.

The net result of this impasse was that the Kurusu-Nomura mission could not meet Hull's demands and their counter-offers were neither accepted in Tokyo or Washington. Eventually the Japanese embassy delivered a note on 7 December indicating a break in relations and that further negotiations were impossible. This was not a declaration of war per se, but one that signaled to all parties Japan's intent for war. Tokyo had intended for Nomura to deliver the note shortly before the Pearl attack, but such an important enciphered document had to be decrypted by non-expert staff, so the Japanese diplomats delivered the note to Hull during the Pearl Harbor attack. Unbeknownst the the Japanese, American Magic intercepts had actually decoded the Japanese messages before their intended recipients. So Hull knew exactly what the Japanese were going to deliver before they arrived in his office.

The Magic intercepts as well as the timing of the note led to a greater sense within Washington that Japan had simply used the Kurusu-Nomura mission as an attempt by Japan to play for time while it prepared for war. Not surprisingly, FDR would emphasize Japanese perfidy during his speech. There is some merit to these charges but they project a coherency and strategic foresight onto the Japanese decision-making that just was not present within the Japanese government. More often than not, the left hand did not know what the right was doing in the Japanese government, so men like Nomura were stuck having to engage in a diplomatic game where they had no real pieces and could not make any serious headway to preserve the peace.