In the age of exploration were Naval officers given Army ranks as an honorary promotion and vice versa?

by SchrodingersNinja

The reason I am asking is because I was playing Sid Meier's Pirates recently. In that game a naval officer is given the ranks of Major and Colonel before being promoted to Admiral.

Was there a common policy in some of the navies at the time to give an honorary Army ranks as a source of prestige?

jschooltiger

Yes, this was a thing that happened, at least in the British navy. Generally speaking, though, the rank that would be given to a naval officer (as a sinecure -- there was not real work attached to it) was Colonel of Marines.

In general aboard ships, the commanding officer of the Marine unit was a captain, who was breveted to Major to avoid there being more than one captain aboard the ship. I can't speak to other navies, but from what I recall about playing Pirates is that the rank you got on retirement was a bit related to your achievements in game, so a rank of major on retiring could easily have been a game mechanic.

I wrote more about sailors and Marine units here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/3oijlw/what_was_the_relation_between_sailors_and_marines/