Were the middle ages as depressing as they seem?

by _DeanRiding
Vespertine

Would you be able to clarify which aspects you're classifying as depressing? Is this in contrast to other pre-modern periods, or simply to the present?

I will post a few old answers about medieval life in Western Europe. Reddit only allows tagging of three users per post, so there will probably be at least one more comment after this one:

u/textandtrowel on [What would a Viking Village of 250 people consist of?] (https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/8bzhmv/what_would_a_viking_village_of_250_people_consist/)

u/Owlettt on The medieval era is often painted as being a very superstitious and unscientific one, but how accurate is this really?

u/sunagainstgold on Timelines of women's rights frequently include gaining the right to own property. But there are plenty of accounts of women in the Middle Ages who owned and managed property. Was here a post-Medieval regression in women's rights or is something else going on?

[How communal were women's chores like dyeing, spinning, weaving, bread baking, ale brewing, etc in the middle and late medieval period in Europe?] (https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/68iu8v/how_communal_were_womens_chores_like_dyeing/) - a lot of this is actually about guilds

What would an English serf do to occupy his time during the long periods of darkness in the fall and winter?

[Medieval England: I'm a healthy 18 year old male serf with no wife or kids and a harsh lord of the manor--what's keeping me on the manor instead of walking off in search of better opportunities on another manor or in some town?] (https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/6zzd06/medieval_england_im_a_healthy_18_year_old_male/)

harry-the-potter

This is a largely unanswerable question, what constitutes depressing is a matter of pure taste. Things were quite different than today in some respects, but that can't be said to be good or bad either. The Middle Ages is a roughly 1000 year period of time during which many millions of people lived, among those many millions of lives there was a great diversity of experience and circumstance, just as today. I don't know how the Middle Ages seem to you because I don't know what kind of information about the period you've consumed, but I will say that popular media (film, television, games etc.) that purport to be set in the period tend to draw their elements from the High Fantasy genre moreso than any historical fact.