Is it fair to say that Germanys defeat at Stalingrad wasn’t the turn of the tide on the Eastern Front, but successfully killed the German advance into the Soviet Union?

by Qualified_Koala

I have to write a paper about a World War II topic for my final project and am trying to finalize my thesis statement.

Rob-With-One-B

The Germans were never again going to make an advance comparable to Barbarossa, or even to Case Blue, if they didn't take the Caucasus oilfields. This is a battle separate but related to Stalingrad, if for entirely the wrong reasons.

Stalingrad was emphatically not considered a priority target in German planning for 1942. The main target for Case Blue was the oilfields around Maikop and Grozny in the Caucasus. The plan envisioned securing the German left flank on the Don River, clearing the Don Bend, and then turning south into the Caucasus to seize the oilfields. Perhaps the only significance of Stalingrad to this particular plan was that it was a prominent crossing point on the Volga and thus potentially an area for the Soviets to mass for counterattacks. Field Marshal von Kleist is quoted as saying "it was just a name on a map to us".

It was only midway through Case Blue that Hitler insisted on capturing Stalingrad rather than just masking it. Army Group South was split into two new army groups, imaginatively called A and B. Army Group A under Field Marshal Fedor von Bock turned south towards the Caucasus and oil in Operation Edelweiss, while Army Group B under Field Marshal Wilhelm List drove for the Volga and Stalingrad in Operation Fischreiher. The original plan was to mask the Volga crossings, then turn south. Army Group South could not do both at the same time. Indeed, Army Group B's strength was so diluted that it had to leave huge stretches of the Don's south west bank unguarded, which later became the assembly areas for the Soviets' Operation Uranus after the Sixth Army had wasted itself trying to capture Stalingrad.

That isn't to say that Case Blue in its original form could have succeeded: to advance from the Donets river to the Caucasus, Army Group South would have to travel distances greater than it had in Operation Barbarossa the previous year, over a much poorer road network, with understrength forces, against a prepared opponent, without the advantage of surprise, and in the middle of a fuel crisis.

Sources:

Antony Beevor, Stalingrad

Robert Kirchubel, Atlas of the Eastern Front, 1941-45

jschooltiger

Hi - we as mods have approved this thread, because while this is a homework question, it is asking for clarification or resources, rather than the answer itself, which is fine according to our rules. This policy is further explained in this Rules Roundtable thread and this META Thread.

As a result, we'd also like to remind potential answerers to follow our rules on homework - please make sure that your answers focus appropriately on clarifications and detailing the resources that OP could be using.

Additionally, while users may be able to help you out with specifics relating to your question, we also have plenty of information on /r/AskHistorians on how to find and understand good sources in general. For instance, please check out our six-part series, "Finding and Understanding Sources", which has a wealth of information that may be useful for finding and understanding information for your essay.