Hi! I'm currently writing my bachelor's thesis on the French protectorate in Morocco (and I'm handing it in today, so I will answer any further questions tomorrow!) so I can weigh in on the Moroccan part of your question.

The answer is a resolute no. The French reflected a lot on the situation in Algeria when the protectorate was formed in 1912. Keep in mind that Algeria had been a department of France since 1848, and it took until the 1870's before civilian rule would replace military rule.

French rule in Algeria was considered to be brutish, military and chauvinistic, and those who would eventually set up the protectorate in Morocco wanted to do everything in their power to learn from their wrongs and define its character as distinctly non-colonial. Marshall Hubert Lyautey, who had fought for the French in Algeria in the 1890's and later became the first Résident-Général in Morocco, was notable in doing so.

As I am writing about the Moroccan independence movement under the protectorate, I will use the Plan de Réformes Marocaines, a 134-page manifesto written by the Comité d'Action Marocaine, the prominent Moroccan independence movement whose members would later form the Istiqlal party which still exists today, as a source. This document, written in 1934, basically serves to ask the French government one question: Why aren't you fulfilling your protectorate duties? The first section of this document (pages 5-18) detail the intentions of the protectorate and the promises of its proponents. Lyautey figures heavily in this section, and his statements are used almost as a moral compass for the French Protectorate. I will translate three of the excerpts from letters that are quoted in this plan:

"I toast to his majesty the Sultan, sovereign of this country, as I have, above everything else, the mission to aid him in reinforcing his authority and to establish order and security. To this end, I bring my devotion and all of my loyalty."

"Your majesty can be assured that the Government of the [French] Republic is resolved to assist him, under the agreements that have been made, in the pacification of his empire, the development of his riches, his progress and of his institutions, in the utmost respect of his customs and his religion"

"[The protectorate's] final characteristic is maintaining the Makhzen and the Sultan in its functions and rights."

These are the characteristics of the protectorate as the members of the Moroccan independence movement saw it, with Marshall Lyautey serving as something like the platonic ideal for how it should be done. Although there are no references to Algeria in this text, it is clear that French policy at least pretended to respect the Morocco's history and sovereignty when they didn't in Algeria. This document really surprised me, I was shocked that this independence movement (whose members would release a single page manifesto demanding independence in 1943) seemed to give the French protectorate so much credit. Their biggest complaint was that the French did not adhere to their own ideals in the end.

Sources: Plan de Réformes Marocaines: http://mohamedhassanouazzani.org/plan-de-reformes-marocaines/

Treaty of Fez (The treaty which formed the Protectorate in 1912): https://fr.wikisource.org/wiki/Trait%C3%A9_de_F%C3%A8s

EDIT: I just realised I left out the most relevant quote by Lyautey:

The concept of the protectorate is one of a country which looks after its own institutions, governs itself and administers itself with its own bodies, under simple control of a European power.

The thing which characterises this concept is control, rather than direct administration.