Italy during WW2 never raised its military budget, at the apex of the war in 1941-1943 Italy actually spent less than what it spent in peace times before the war broke out, why ? Why, after 20 years they had to mobilize the economy, they never mobilized the economy for total war ?

by [deleted]

[deleted]

Klesk_vs_Xaero

In order to give a better answer to your question, it might help to better understand the origin of your data. It appears in fact that military expenditure increased during the war; albeit perhaps a bit less than you would expect - you should also be mindful of the fact that Italy was at war (if not under such extreme circumstances as during 1940-43) in 1935-36 as well as 1937-38.

Data of the Italian Tresure - http://www.rgs.mef.gov.it/_Documenti/VERSIONE-I/Pubblicazioni/Studi-e-do/La-spesa-dello-stato/La_spesa_dello_Stato_dall_unit_d_Italia.pdf - provide the following picture for percentage of defense expenses over total expenditure.

year defense
1910 22.0
1911 24.0
1912 28.9
1913 30.9
1914 46.7
1915 69.8
1916 74.4
1917 70.2
1918 64.0
1919 55.9
1920 34.1
1921 17.5
1922 18.8
1923 21.8
1924 20.1
1925 18.0
1926 20.7
1927 17.9
1928 16.1
1929 19.5
1930 20.6
1931 19.9
1932 21.3
1933 19.2
1934 19.6
1935 19.6
1936 23.1
1937 30.4
1938 31.7
1939 37.3
1940 53.6
1941 58.5
1942 55.2
1943 55.0

As you can see a clear increase in proportion is evident.

For total expenditure, the increase is even more apparent, as the percentage of 1935 has to be computed over a total of 47 billion Euros (2009) as compared to the 27 of the year before. The re-evaluation is clearly necessary as Italy underwent a deflation process during the late 1920s as well as a persistent economical slump the kept going well into the late 1930s.

Data for total expenditure in contemporary values may therefore appear misleading. For instance the 14.2945 million Euros (in contemporary values i.e equal to Lire of the time divided per 1936.27) of 1928 are "equivalent" - in monetary values, not as quota of resources allocated - to 23 billions; while the 13.0281 million Euros of 1934 are equivalent ot over 27.

It also bears the question that military expenditure, military budget and the way econimics looks at agrregated expenditure are not the same thing. If you are looking explicitly for the budget approved year by year; military expenditure in case of War would largely exceed the budget - it also doesn't have to fall entirely within the military expenditure voice in the official data (state participated steel works did not, as far as plant investments went, but military purchases of steel would).

A further source of complication is given by the fact that data for the 1940-43 are not well organized; basically after 1943 the care that the finance administration put into keeping every voice well accounted for proved insufficient for the chaotic nature of war trade. There is a lot of guesswork on the actual expenses of the nation in that time.

Anyways, these are data for all expenses, in 2009 value.

Year total (Billion Euros 2009)
1910 9.9
1914 15.9
1915 28.2
1916 39.6
1917 42.6
1918 37.9
1919 33.9
1920 23.5
1921 22.1
1922 30.0
1923 32.8
1924 23.2
1925 16.2
1926 15.6
1927 20.4
1928 23.0
1929 19.5
1930 19.8
1931 23.5
1932 22.7
1933 25.6
1934 27.1
1935 47.1
1936 53.8
1937 37.6
1938 34.0
1939 40.0
1940 56.3
1941 65.6
1942 70.1
1943 42.7

Taking this into account. Defense expenditure hit a maximum of roughly 37 Billion Euros (2009) in 1942, compared to roughly 30 Billion Euros (2009) in 1917 - the worst year of WW1 (of course over a different total budget) - and compared to roughly 5.5 Billion Euros (2009) in 1934 - the last full year of peace.