I really want to get in digging, but I've long since been aware of the fact there's loads of trash out there. I want to get in with a sturdy understanding so I can better spot the BS when it shows up, as opposed to falling into the same traps teenage me fell into when I was first interested in Middle Ages Europe.
Any and all recommendations are appreciated. Thanks!
Have you checked out the pre-Columbian section from the Books and Resources list?