I am a rifleman in the US 1st Infantry Division just before Operation Torch in WW2. How many men in my unit will I recognize by the end of the war?

by RCTommy

Assuming I make it through the whole war unscathed but remain a private and never get transferred, how many of the original 1942 men will still be around in my squad/platoon/company by the end of the war? I know that casualty rates in the infantry divisions could push 200 percent over the course of the war, but how would this actually affect the men I know? Would casualties tend to mostly occur in new replacements after a certain point of attrition, or would my unit eventually reach a point where I would practically be the only original man remaining?

the_howling_cow

I've written extensively about the danger of combat for U.S. frontline troops several times;

The odds are pretty likely that you'd recognize next to none. The majority of casualties in U.S. divisions which had infantry occurred in infantry units, as they are relatively squishy and are not protected by rolling metal boxes or distance from the front lines.

Table 5-9. Distribution of Battle Losses by Branch (Divisions)

Branch Infantry division (percentage) Armored division (percentage) Airborne division (percentage)
Infantry 93.0 62.0 85.6
Artillery 2.4 3.6 6.9
Armor [includes Cavalry] 2.0 23.1 0.0
Engineers 1.5 3.3 3.9
All others 1.1 8.0 3.6

87.4% of losses in infantry units occurred among riflemen and heavy weapons crewmen.

Table 5-13. Distribution of Battle Losses by Branch Within Corps and Larger Units in the Combat Zone as Percentage of Total Battle Losses

Branch Percentage
Infantry 81.9
Artillery 4.5
(Field) (3.6)
(Antiaircraft) (0.9)
Armor 6.6
(Armor) (2.9)
(Cavalry) (2.3)
(Tank Destroyer) (1.4)
Corps of Engineers 3.2
Medical Department 2.8
Signal Corps 0.2
Quartermaster Corps 0.1
Ordnance Department 0.2
Transportation Corps Negligible
Chemical Corps 0.3
Corps of Military Police 0.1
Miscellaneous 0.1

The 1st Infantry Division suffered 20,659 battle casualties during the war; 3,616 killed in action, 15,208 wounded in action, 499 missing in action, and 1,336 made prisoners of war.

Theater Total battle casualties KIA WIA MIA POW
All theaters 20,659 3,616 15,208 499 1,336
Mediterranean (Algeria-French Morocco, Tunisia, Sicily) 5,285 903 3,681 170 531
European (Normandy, Northern France, Rhineland, Ardennes-Alsace, Central Europe) 15,374 2,713 11,527 329 805

Company L of the 134th Infantry Regiment, 35th Infantry Division received about 3.4 times its original complement (193) in replacements (663) during its service in the European Theater from July 1944 to May 1945. Only 11 original members of the unit did not become some type of casualty. The 35th Infantry Division suffered 15,822 battle casualties during the war; 2,485 killed in action, 11,526 wounded in action, 340 missing in action, and 1,471 made prisoners of war.

Several of the men reported as wounded or injured in action later died of their wounds, but it was not listed as such on the company morning reports from where these numbers were taken. The numbers of men listed as prisoners of war comes from a list of 134th Infantry Regiment men confirmed to be held prisoner in Germany as of late March 1945, and is deducted from the number originally reported as missing.

Month KIA DOW SWA SIA LWA LIA MIA POW Sick NBC Total
7/44 37 3 16 111 5 1 6 6 10 195
8/44 9 1 7 36 6 3 15 3 80
9/44 15 2 1 30 3 13 2 1 67
10/44 3 3 3 2 11
11/44 24 12 124 8 1 20 43 232
12/44 8 13 46 7 22 89 14 3 202
1/45 6 3 2 16 21 14 62
2/45 2 2 6 3 10 1 24
3/45 1 28 1 6 36
4/45 4 1 9 14
5/45 2 2
Total 105 4 55 3 404 52 30 108 101 63 925

Sources:

United States. Department of the Army. FM 101-10-1 Field Manual Staff Officers Field Manual Organizational, Technical and Logistic Data (Unclassified Data). Washington, D.C.: Department of the Army, 1976.

United States. United States Army. Adjutant General’s Department. Army Battle Casualties and Nonbattle Deaths in World War II, Final Report, 7 December 1941 - 31 December 1946. Washington, D.C.: Statistical and Accounting Branch, Office of the Adjutant General, United States Army, 1953.